ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Property Damage Claims Supervisor Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Diedre Moire Corp.

Claims Manager

Hoffman Estates, IL · On-site

$120K - $150K/yr

Insurance Claims Manager Claims Supervisor Team Leader Leadership Commercial Auto General Liability Automobile Insurance Commercial Claims Personal Bodily Injury Property Damage #DiedreMoire ...

New

Diedre Moire Corp.

Claims Manager

Pineville, NC · On-site

$120K - $150K/yr

Insurance Claims Manager Claims Supervisor Team Leader Leadership Commercial Auto General Liability Automobile Insurance Commercial Claims Personal Bodily Injury Property Damage #DiedreMoire ...

previous page

Showing results 41-60

All JobsFinance And Insurance JobsInsurance JobsInsurance Claims Specialist JobsProperty Damage Claims Supervisor Jobs

Property Damage Claims Supervisor information

See salary details

$35K

$87.9K

$139K

How much do property damage claims supervisor jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 12, 2026, the average yearly pay for property damage claims supervisor in the United States is $87,861.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $68,000.00 and $105,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does a property damage claims supervisor do?

A Property Damage Claims Supervisor oversees the claims process for property damage, ensuring that claims are handled efficiently and in accordance with company policies and legal requirements. They supervise claims adjusters, review complex or high-value claims, and provide guidance on claim investigations and settlements. Additionally, they may handle escalated cases, train new staff, and ensure customer service standards are met throughout the claims process.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a property damage claims supervisor, and why are they important?

To excel as a Property Damage Claims Supervisor, you need expertise in insurance claims processes, strong analytical skills, and experience in property damage assessment, often supported by a bachelor's degree and relevant industry certifications. Familiarity with claims management software, estimating tools like Xactimate, and regulatory compliance systems is typically required. Outstanding leadership, problem-solving abilities, and effective communication are crucial soft skills for managing teams and resolving conflicts. These competencies ensure efficient claims resolution, regulatory adherence, and high-quality customer service.

What are some common challenges faced by property damage claims supervisors, and how can they be addressed?

Property Damage Claims Supervisors often face challenges such as managing high claim volumes, ensuring timely and accurate settlements, and coordinating effectively with both internal teams and external partners like adjusters and contractors. To address these challenges, supervisors need to foster strong communication skills, implement efficient workflow processes, and stay updated on industry regulations and best practices. Building a supportive team environment and utilizing technology for tracking and reporting can also help streamline operations and reduce stress for both supervisors and their teams.

What is the difference between Property Damage Claims Supervisor vs Property Damage Adjuster?

AspectProperty Damage Claims SupervisorProperty Damage Adjuster
CredentialsInsurance licenses, claims handling certificationsInsurance licenses, claims handling certifications
Work EnvironmentSupervises claims team, office and field settingsEvaluates damages, inspects properties, fieldwork
Employer & IndustryInsurance companies, claims departmentsInsurance companies, independent adjusters
Search & Comparison IntentUnderstanding supervisory roles in claimsAssessing damages and settling claims

The Property Damage Claims Supervisor oversees claims teams and manages the claims process, focusing on supervision and coordination. In contrast, the Property Damage Adjuster primarily evaluates damages on-site and determines claim settlements. Both roles require similar certifications and work within insurance companies, but their responsibilities differ in scope and focus.

How much do property damage claims supervisors make in the US?

Property damage claims supervisors in the US typically earn an average salary between $60,000 and $85,000 annually, depending on experience, location, and employer size. They oversee claims processing, coordinate with adjusters, and ensure accurate claim resolution, often requiring knowledge of insurance policies and claims management software.

What cities are hiring for Property Damage Claims Supervisor jobs?

Cities with the most Property Damage Claims Supervisor job openings:

What states have the most Property Damage Claims Supervisor jobs?

States with the most job openings for Property Damage Claims Supervisor jobs include:

What are popular job titles related to Property Damage Claims Supervisor jobs?

For Property Damage Claims Supervisor jobs, the most frequently searched job titles are:

Infographic showing various Property Damage Claims Supervisor job openings in the United States as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 76% Full Time, 19% Part Time, 1% Temporary, 2% Contract, and 1% Nights. Highlights an 98% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 1% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $87,861 per year, or $42.2 per hour.

Auto Property Damage Claims Specialist

Oak Brook, IL • On-site, Remote

First Chicago Insurance
Insurance Services • 51 - 200 employees
Learn more about First Chicago Insuranceexternal

$41K - $75K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 10 days ago

First Chicago Insurance rating

5.7

Company rating: 5.7 out of 10

Based on 7 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

Job description

Are you unhappy at your present job?

Are you going nowhere in your current position?

Is it time for a change?

Are you an experienced Auto Liability Claims Specialist looking to join a growing company where you will be rewarded for your hard work, and have future upward career growth opportunities?

If you answered YES to the above, it's time to talk to First Chicago Insurance Company!

We offer:

  • Competitive Salaries
  • First Year Hiring Bonus for direct applicants
  • Excellent benefits
  • Growth opportunities!

Apply only if you consider yourself a career professional who loves to work, because we work hard here!

If you are an experienced CLAIMS PROFESSIONAL (with many years of auto and especially nonstandard auto related experience) we'll make sure you are COMPENSATED AS A PROFESSIONAL!!

We have openings in our Bedford Park, IL and Oak Brook, IL offices!

This talented individual must possess previous experience in the investigation, determination of coverage, prompt evaluation of both First and Third Party auto property damage claims with an eye towards prompt, courteous and economical resolution of both First and Third Party related property damage claims.

DUTIES & RESPONSIBILITIES:

  • Review and determine course of action on each file assigned, utilizing technical knowledge and experience for the purpose of supporting final disposition of a loss
  • Conduct thorough investigations and keep accurate and relevant documentation of file activity on each claim assigned including coverage liability, status and damages that are applicable for each claim
  • Honor/decline/negotiate first and third party liability claims upon completion of coverage/policy investigation and analysis of damages and liability
  • Work directly with internal and external customers to develop evidence and establish facts on assigned claims
  • Organize, plan and prioritize work activities to keep up with current assignments and to ensure prompt conclusion of claims
  • Prepare and present claim evaluations for the appropriate settlement authority
  • Notify the Underwriting Department of any adverse information uncovered in the course of the investigation
  • Familiarity with unfair claim practices in states where doing business
  • Conduct business with vendors in a professional manner while maintaining a reasonable expense factor and upholding the company's reputation for quality service
  • Provide customer service both to internal and external customers
  • Handle other duties as assigned

QUALIFICATIONS REQUIRED:

  • 2 years previous auto liability and PD claims experience A MUST!
  • Non-Standard Auto Claims experience a plus, not required
  • Minimum 5 years experience in auto liability and PD claims for Hybrid consideration.
  • Excellent analytical, organizational, interpersonal and communication (verbal, written, phone) skills
  • General working knowledge of policies, file procedures, state rules and regulations
  • Ability to pass written examinations where required by state statutes to become a licensed Claims Adjuster

Preferred:

  • College degree
  • Prior auto claims experience
  • Ability to use on-line claims system
  • Bi-lingual a plus!

First Chicago Insurance Company provides a competitive benefits package to all full- time employees. Following are some of the perks First Chicago employees receive:

  • Competitive Salaries
  • Commitment to your Training & Development
  • Medical and Dental and Vision Reimbursement
  • Short Term Disability/Long Term Disability
  • Life Insurance
  • Flexible Spending Account
  • Telemedicine Benefit
  • 401k with a generous company match
  • Paid Time Off and Paid Holidays
  • Tuition Reimbursement
  • Wellness Program
  • Fun company sponsored events
  • And so much more!

Estimated Compensation Range: $41,600/year-$75,000/year*

*Published ranges are estimates. Offered compensation will be based on experience, skills, education, certifications, and geographic location. In addition, starting salary may vary by position depending on whether the position is in-office, hybrid or remote.

What First Chicago Insurance employees say

Pay

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Apply