1

Pie Insurance Jobs in Wisconsin (NOW HIRING)

Pizza Maker

Wausau, WI · On-site

$11 - $13.50/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Pizza Maker

Franklin, WI · On-site

$11 - $13.50/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Pizza Maker

Fitchburg, WI · On-site

$13 - $15/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Pizza Maker

Whitewater, WI · On-site

$13 - $15/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Pizza Maker

Wauwatosa, WI · On-site

$11 - $13.50/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Pizza Maker

Oshkosh, WI · On-site

$13.50/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Pizza Maker (Regent St)

Madison, WI · On-site

$13 - $15/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

New

Shift Leader

Oshkosh, WI · On-site

$15.50/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Shift Leader

Fitchburg, WI · On-site

$14 - $16.50/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Shift Leader

Wauwatosa, WI · On-site

$13 - $15/hr

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie. * Flexible Scheduling * Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance* * 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match

Showing results 21-40

Pie Insurance information

See Wisconsin salary details

$13

$20

$29

How much do pie insurance jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 7, 2026, the average hourly pay for pie insurance in Wisconsin is $20.53, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $16.97 and $23.27 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance underwriter, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Insurance Underwriter, you need strong analytical skills, attention to detail, and typically a bachelor's degree in finance, business, or a related field. Familiarity with underwriting software, risk assessment tools, and industry certifications such as CPCU or AINS are commonly required. Excellent communication, decision-making, and negotiation abilities help underwriters collaborate effectively and explain complex decisions to stakeholders. These competencies ensure accurate risk evaluation, profitable policy decisions, and strong client relationships in a competitive insurance environment.

What are some common challenges faced by employees working at Pie Insurance, and how can they be addressed?

Working at Pie Insurance often involves adapting to a fast-paced, technology-driven environment as the company is rapidly growing in the insurtech sector. Employees may face challenges such as staying up-to-date with evolving insurance regulations, learning new tools, and collaborating across remote or hybrid teams. Proactively communicating with team members, engaging in continuous learning, and leveraging Pie’s internal resources and training programs can help overcome these challenges. The company also encourages feedback and cross-functional collaboration, providing opportunities to grow and adapt within the organization.

What is Pie Insurance?

Pie Insurance is an insurance technology company that specializes in providing workers’ compensation insurance to small businesses. They use data analytics and technology to offer more affordable and accessible coverage compared to traditional insurers. By streamlining the quote and purchase process, Pie Insurance aims to simplify workers’ comp for small business owners and help them better protect their employees. The company operates primarily online and partners with a network of insurance agents to reach a broad range of clients.

What is the difference between Pie Insurance vs Commercial Insurance Agent?

AspectPie InsuranceCommercial Insurance Agent
Required CredentialsLicenses in insurance, possibly state-specificLicenses in insurance, often state-specific
Work EnvironmentOffice-based, insurance tech platformOffice or client-site, sales-focused
Employer & Industry UsageInsurtech companies, digital insurance providersInsurance agencies, brokerages
Common Search & Comparison IntentUnderstanding insurtech vs traditional insurance providersComparing insurance sales roles

Pie Insurance primarily operates as an insurtech company offering small business workers' compensation insurance online, focusing on digital solutions. Commercial Insurance Agents typically work for agencies or brokerages, providing personalized insurance advice and selling policies. While both roles require insurance licenses and industry knowledge, Pie Insurance emphasizes technology-driven insurance solutions, whereas Commercial Insurance Agents focus on client relationships and sales in a traditional setting.

What are popular job titles related to Pie Insurance jobs in Wisconsin? For Pie Insurance jobs in Wisconsin, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What cities in Wisconsin are hiring for Pie Insurance jobs? Cities in Wisconsin with the most Pie Insurance job openings:
Infographic showing various Pie Insurance job openings in Wisconsin as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 75% Full Time, 20% Part Time, and 4% Contract. Highlights an 91% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 8% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $42,707 per year, or $20.5 per hour.

$11 - $13.50/hr

Full-time, Part-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement

Re-posted 22 days ago


Toppers Pizza rating

5.5

Company rating: 5.5 out of 10

Based on 21 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz


Job description

Description
Pizza Makers Extraordinaire Needed at Toppers Pizza - Become a Pizza Picasso!
Our Pizza People are the heart and soul of our company, bringing great food and memorable experiences that friends and families connect over to our local communities. At Toppers Pizza we knead passionate Team Members like you to sprinkle some flavor and fun into our kitchen!
Whether you are searching for a full-time or part-time job, or you want a flexible schedule because you are in school or you just want a second job for some extra cash, Toppers knows we are the right fit for you!
Slice of Heaven: Enjoy up to $13.50/hour (hourly rate + tips) to spice up your bank account, making it grate for your pocket!
Responsibilities
  • Prep for day and night shifts by making dough and cutting fresh veggie toppings, which are all important pieces as to how we deliver on our promise of serving only high-quality food.
  • Stock ingredients in the various workstations.
  • Greet guests by making them feel welcome.
  • Take orders by accurately using the Point-of-Sale system, processing cash and/or credit cards transactions.
  • Follow recipes to prepare our delicious food for our Toppers Pizza fanatics.
  • Ensure kitchen and store cleanliness by complying with food sanitation requirements, properly handling food, and ensuring correct storage.

Benefits
  • Competitive pay package
  • Referral bonuses for stacking up your dough and bringing more friends to the "pizza" pie.
  • Flexible Scheduling
  • Up to 90% Company Paid Medical Insurance*
  • 401(k) Plan with up to a 4% Company Match
  • Payroll Advance on earned income up to $500 per pay period
  • Holiday Pay on certain holidays that we are open
  • Meal Discounts (70% While Working!)
  • Rapid advancement opportunities with our Manager-in-Training program - climb the pizza ladder with pay raises at each level!
  • Free Uniforms T-Shirt to wear with pride as you spin dough like a pro
  • FUN Atmosphere
  • Flexible Spending Accounts (Dependent Care & Health)*
  • Health Savings Account*
  • Voluntary Group Dental, Vision, and Life Insurance*
  • Voluntary Hospital Indemnity, Accident, and Critical Illness Insurance*
  • Voluntary Group Pet Insurance*

*For those who meet the qualifications
For you to be successful at Toppers Pizza, as a Team Member, you must be willing to come to work and exhibit "The Toppers Way".
This means that You:
  • Live With Integrity-- say what you mean, and do what you say, especially when nobody's watching!
  • Have Fun-- yes, it is work but enjoy it!
  • Always project a positive image & energy-- smile, in-person and on the phone.
  • Are noticeably friendly & give each customer individual attention.
  • Want to be a part of building something special -- we are building a special company!
  • Bring It...With Passion-- come to work ready to rock and make it happen.
  • Kill it at the details --anticipate needs and react when noticing any dissatisfaction.
  • Can tell it like it is with tact -- honesty with a positive spin.
  • Are self-disciplined with a strong drive to succeed -- you need little direction before you take the reins with a can-do attitude.

Grab this opportunity by the slice and join us at Toppers where every day is a pizza party waiting to happen! Apply today and let us create some dough-lightful memories together!

What Toppers Pizza employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom