ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Permanent Substitute Teacher Jobs in Rutherford, NJ

iLearn Schools

On-Call Substitute Teacher

Fair Lawn, NJ · On-site

$150/day

Substitute/Substitute Teacher Date Posted: 4/29/2026 Location: iLearn Schools Date Available: 08/17 ... Ability to follow lesson plans, left by the permanent teacher. * Required criminal history ...

iLearn Schools

On-Call Substitute Teacher

Fair Lawn, NJ · On-site

$150/day

ON-CALL SUBSTITUTE TEACHER Compensation: $150/day QUALIFICATIONS: * Valid New Jersey Substitute ... Ability to follow lesson plans, left by the permanent teacher. * Required criminal history ...

previous pagenext page

Showing results 21-40

All JobsPermanent Substitute Teacher JobsPermanent Substitute Teacher Jobs in Rutherford, NJ

Permanent Substitute Teacher information

See Rutherford, NJ salary details

$19.4K

$43.1K

$70.3K

How much do permanent substitute teacher jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 6, 2026, the average yearly pay for permanent substitute teacher in Rutherford, NJ is $43,065.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $31,600.00 and $51,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a permanent substitute teacher?

A Permanent Substitute Teacher is an educator who is assigned to one school or district for an extended period, often for the entire school year. Unlike regular substitute teachers who are called in as needed, permanent substitutes have a consistent schedule and are available to fill in for absent teachers at a moment’s notice. They may also support classroom activities, supervise students, and assist with administrative duties. This role provides greater stability for students and staff and ensures classroom continuity.

Can a permanent substitute teacher be a permanent teacher?

A permanent substitute teacher is typically hired to fill in for regular teachers on a long-term basis but is not usually considered a permanent teacher unless they meet specific district requirements and complete necessary certifications or licensure. Transitioning from a substitute to a permanent teacher often involves applying for a full-time teaching position and meeting the district's credentialing standards.

What is the difference between Permanent Substitute Teacher vs Long-Term Substitute Teacher?

FeaturePermanent Substitute TeacherLong-Term Substitute Teacher
CredentialsTypically requires a substitute teaching license or certificationRequires a substitute teaching license or certification, sometimes with additional qualifications
Work EnvironmentWorks across multiple classrooms and subjects, often in various schoolsWorks in a specific classroom for an extended period, covering a teacher's absence
DurationUsually short-term, day-to-day assignmentsExtended period, often weeks or months
Employer & Industry UsageUsed by schools for daily substitutesUsed for filling long-term teacher absences

While both roles require similar certifications and involve working in school environments, a Permanent Substitute Teacher typically fills short-term gaps across multiple classrooms, whereas a Long-Term Substitute Teacher covers a specific classroom for an extended period. The main difference lies in the duration and scope of the assignment.

Do permanent substitute teachers get paid more?

Permanent substitute teachers typically receive a higher daily rate than short-term substitutes because they are assigned to a specific school or district for an extended period. However, their pay is generally less than full-time teachers, and salary varies based on district policies, experience, and certifications. Additional benefits may be available depending on the school district's employment terms.

Can you make a living off of being a permanent substitute teacher?

A permanent substitute teacher can earn a full-time income depending on the school district, experience, and hours worked. However, salaries are often lower than those of full-time teachers, and many substitute teachers supplement their income with additional work or benefits. Certification and a strong reputation can improve earning potential in this role.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a permanent substitute teacher, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Permanent Substitute Teacher, you generally need a bachelor’s degree (often in education or a related field) and, in many districts, a teaching credential or substitute permit. Familiarity with classroom management software, digital learning platforms, and standard curriculum materials is typically required. Adaptability, strong communication, and the ability to quickly build rapport with students and staff are essential soft skills in this role. These qualifications and skills ensure effective instruction, continuity of learning, and a positive classroom environment during teacher absences.

What do long-term substitute teachers do?

Long-term substitute teachers fill teaching positions for extended periods, often several weeks or months, covering for regular teachers who are absent. They plan and deliver lessons, manage classroom behavior, and follow curriculum guidelines, often requiring familiarity with teaching tools and certifications such as a substitute teaching license. Their role ensures continuity of instruction during the regular teacher's absence.

How does the daily routine of a permanent substitute teacher differ from that of a regular classroom teacher?

As a Permanent Substitute Teacher, your daily routine is often more varied than that of a regular classroom teacher. Instead of having a consistent group of students and a set curriculum, you may cover multiple classes and subjects throughout the day, adapting quickly to different teaching styles and lesson plans. This role requires flexibility and strong classroom management skills, as you'll step into different environments and support students' learning with minimal preparation time. You also have opportunities to build relationships with staff and gain exposure to various grade levels, which can be beneficial for career advancement.
What are the most commonly searched types of Substitute Teacher jobs in Rutherford, NJ? The most popular types of Substitute Teacher jobs in Rutherford, NJ are:
What cities near Rutherford, NJ are hiring for Permanent Substitute Teacher jobs? Cities near Rutherford, NJ with the most Permanent Substitute Teacher job openings:
Permanent Substitute Teacher jobs near you
Infographic showing various Permanent Substitute Teacher job openings in Rutherford, NJ as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 77% Full Time, 19% Part Time, 1% Temporary, and 3% Contract. Highlights an 99% Physical, and 1% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $43,065 per year, or $20.7 per hour.

Lower School Permanent Substitute Teacher

Abraham Joshua Heschel School

Manhattan, NY

$55K - $60K/yr

Full-time

Re-posted 29 days ago

Job description

Abraham Joshua Heschel School is currently seeking a permanent Lower School substitute teacher for the 2025-26 school year. 

This is a full-time exempt position that follows the standard departmental five day schedule. You may be assigned to one classroom for the day or rotate between classrooms as needed. , however, you may be asked to step in to assist other dictions as needed. Attendance at a weekly faculty meeting and lunch/recess coverage are also required. 

Abraham Joshua Heschel School, located in New York City, is an independent Jewish school, N-12, unaffiliated with any single movement or synagogue. The school's approach to education is governed by profound respect for children. It nurtures their curiosity, cultivates their imagination, encourages creative expression, values their initiative and engenders critical thinking skills. The Heschel School is dedicated to inspiring its graduates to become responsible adults and active, compassionate citizens of the Jewish world and world communities.

Minimum Requirements:

  • College degree required.

  • Experience working with children in an educational setting.

Qualified applicants should upload a cover letter and resume. To apply, follow this link: 

https://workforcenow.adp.com/mascsr/default/mdf/recruitment/recruitment.html?cid=5db03d9d-83a7-470f-a3eb-1942264884b7&ccId=19000101_000001&jobId=569329&source=CC2&lang=en_US


In compliance with federal law, all persons hired will be required to verify identity and eligibility to work in the United States and to complete the required employment eligibility verification document form upon hire.


Abraham Joshua Heschel School is an Equal Opportunity Employer.


The full-time equivalent salary range is $55,000 - $60,000, depending on years of experience.