1

Manager Captive Insurance Agent Jobs in Indiana, PA

... management, member engagement, provider solutions, payment integrity, claims cost containment, and ... As a Licensed Health Insurance Agent, you'll provide consultative sales support to customers ...

... management, member engagement, provider solutions, payment integrity, claims cost containment, and ... As a Licensed Health Insurance Agent, you'll provide consultative sales support to customers ...

At least 1 year of experience selling annuities, retirement products, insurance products, or related financial services. * Proven success in business development, sales, and relationship management.

Right of Way (ROW) Agent (Field Based)

Indiana, PA ยท On-site +1

$34.19 - $40.20/hr

... management software. * Knowledgeable in real estate values and accepted real estate appraisal ... insurance to benefits eligible * employees. *Benefits Eligibility is limited to Regular employees ...

Manager, Data Engineer (Remote)

Home, PA ยท Remote

$100K - $174K/yr

Build agent-ready data assets, including semantic layer components (ontology, taxonomy, domain ... Insurance data modelingforanalytics and actuarial-ready data structures * MLOpsfamiliarity ...

Manager, Data Engineer (Remote)

Home, PA ยท Remote

$100K - $174K/yr

Build agent-ready data assets, including semantic layer components (ontology, taxonomy, domain ... Insurance data modelingforanalytics and actuarial-ready data structures * MLOpsfamiliarity ...

Remote Insurance Sales Representative | Flexible Schedule | Commission-Based This position offers flexible work hours and clear paths for advancement into leadership and management. You will work ...

Remote Insurance Sales Representative | Flexible Schedule | Commission-Based This position offers flexible work hours and clear paths for advancement into leadership and management. You will work ...

Remote Insurance Sales Representative | Flexible Schedule | Commission-Based This position offers flexible work hours and clear paths for advancement into leadership and management. You will work ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Manager Captive Insurance Agent information

See Indiana, PA salary details

$22.8K

$59.4K

$111K

How much do manager captive insurance agent jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 26, 2026, the average yearly pay for manager captive insurance agent in Indiana, PA is $59,426.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $40,700.00 and $70,400.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Manager Captive Insurance Agent vs Captive Insurance Agent?

AspectManager Captive Insurance AgentCaptive Insurance Agent
CredentialsLicenses, insurance certifications, management experienceLicenses, insurance certifications
Work EnvironmentSupervisory role, team management, agency oversightIndividual sales, client interaction, policy selling
Employer & IndustryInsurance agencies, captive insurance companiesInsurance agencies, captive insurers
Search & Comparison IntentUnderstanding managerial roles in captive insuranceSales roles within captive insurance

The main difference between a Manager Captive Insurance Agent and a Captive Insurance Agent lies in their responsibilities. The manager oversees team operations, manages client portfolios, and ensures compliance, requiring management experience and certifications. In contrast, a captive insurance agent primarily focuses on selling policies and client interactions. Both roles operate within insurance companies or agencies, but the managerial position involves leadership and oversight, while the agent role emphasizes sales and customer service.

Is it better to be a manager captive insurance agent?

Being a manager captive insurance agent involves overseeing agents within a captive insurance company, requiring strong leadership, industry knowledge, and sales skills. It often offers stability, a structured environment, and potential for higher earnings through team management, but may also involve strict company policies and limited product flexibility.

What cities near Indiana, PA are hiring for Manager Captive Insurance Agent jobs?

Cities near Indiana, PA with the most Manager Captive Insurance Agent job openings:

Infographic showing various Manager Captive Insurance Agent job openings in Indiana, PA as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 100% Full Time. Highlights an 67% In-person, and 33% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $59,426 per year, or $28.6 per hour.

Licensed Personal Lines Insurance Agent

DBD Staffing

Indiana, PA โ€ข On-site

$39K - $54K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Life, Retirement, PTO

This job post hasย expired today.ย Applications are no longer accepted.


Job description

Licensed Personal Lines Insurance Agent

Opportunities at their Indiana and Duncansville, PA offices!

Our Client, a local, awarding winning, independent Insurance Agency, is seeking a professional, outgoing, dedicated, and client focused, Personal Lines Agent / Customer Service Representative to join their fast-growing team.

The Personal Lines Insurance Agent / Customer Service Representative is responsible for the production of new insurance sales, specifically homeowner, auto, and/or personal lines insurance. The Agent is the initial point of contact for prospects and policyholders on all products and coverages.

Overview of Responsibilities:

  • Develop and pursue sales opportunities by initiating cross-sales calls and pursuing leads while servicing new and existing Personal Lines Client Accounts
  • Respond to customer questions, amending policies, explaining available services and products, and providing information on insurance pricing
  • Customize insurance packages to suit individual customers’ needs and requirements
  • Obtain prospects and actively pursue and create interest by telephone calls, emails, writing letters, or making personal visits
  • Call on new business, discuss existing policies, review liability limits and exposures, explore other coverage needs, evaluate replacement costs, round out accounts, and bind renewals
  • Manage the sales cycle from start to finish through active listening, negotiation, and closing new business as well as providing quotes, premiums, and comparing rates
  • Develop and promote strong relationships with prospects and clients to generate new business
  • Collaborate with new clients to understand their needs, gather necessary data, research policy options, present options, finalize and bind new coverage, cancel old policies, and negotiate with carriers when necessary
  • Conduct a policy review and engages with probing questions to develop a thorough understanding of the clients’ needs and recommend coverages
  • Perform administrative duties as needed such as answering phones, taking payments, documenting in agency’s management system, greeting visitors, etc.

Qualifications:

  • PA Property & Casualty license preferred, if currently studying must have ability to take test in next few weeks
  • PA Life, Accident and Health Licenses and /or Commercial line experience a plus! Must be willing to obtain Life, Accident and Health Licenses
  • Experience in Insurance is preferred, Benefits and Health Insurance knowledge is helpful
  • Organized, detail-oriented, & initiative-taker who can multitask in fast-paced dynamic environment
  • Proficient with MS Office, general computer skills, and ability to learn and continuously improve technical skills
  • Ability to work with multiple computer applications and demonstrate speed, accuracy, and attention to detail
  • Demonstrate strong customer focus with ability and tact to manage difficult customer interactions
  • Proactive problem solver, able to solve complex problems without direct supervision
  • Positive Collaborator! Gets along with everyone and making teamwork and unity a priority
  • Strong ethical values, excellent work ethics, honesty, and integrity
  • Strong negotiation skills; Persistent with strong follow-through and follow-up
  • Good listener: ability to hear, understand, and communicate complex business challenges
  • Possess excellent math and reading skills to accurately perform simple tasks and calculations
  • Connections within the local communities and independently involved in the local community preferred
  • Participate in courses for insurance/sales skills. Maintain current knowledge of underwriting requirements of carriers. Keep current with industry trends by reading appropriate journals and company bulletins
  • Must be able to pass a Criminal and Credit Background Check

Schedule and Compensation Overview:

· Monday - Friday 8:30am to 5:00pm

· Hourly position – pay based on current PA insurance licenses and experience

· Agency is aggressively growing. Monthly and Quarterly bonuses!

· Commission for production and profitability of sales

· Healthcare: 80% Agency paid UPMC health insurance or monthly Health Stipend

· Matching Simple IRA

· Paid time off and holiday pay

· AD&D - Life Insurance Long & Short-Term Disability (100% Agency Paid)

· Education Assistance

All postings listed by DBD Staffing are direct hire job opportunities.

DBD does not offer temporary staffing.

We assist hiring teams by advertising, searching, and pre-screening candidates.