1

Insurance Utilization Reviewer Jobs in Madison, WI

... utilization review processes to assure continuity for the most appropriate level of care for ... Perform insurance benefit verifications and secure initial pre-authorization for treatment and ...

... utilization review processes to assure continuity for the most appropriate level of care for ... Perform insurance benefit verifications and secure initial pre-authorization for treatment and ...

Pharmacy Vendor Coordinator

Madison, WI ยท On-site +1

$19 - $24.75/hr

Understanding of pharmacy claims processing, formulary management, and basic utilization review ... Health insurance, dental insurance, and telehealth services start DAY 1 * Professional and ...

New

Pharmacy Vendor Coordinator

Madison, WI ยท On-site +1

$19 - $24.75/hr

Understanding of pharmacy claims processing, formulary management, and basic utilization review ... Health insurance, dental insurance, and telehealth services start DAY 1 * Professional and ...

New

... utilization review processes to assure continuity for the most appropriate level of care for ... Perform insurance benefit verifications and secure initial pre-authorization for treatment and ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Insurance Utilization Reviewer information

See Madison, WI salary details

$31.2K

$38.3K

$44.3K

How much do insurance utilization reviewer jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 6, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance utilization reviewer in Madison, WI is $38,282.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $34,300.00 and $42,300.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is an insurance utilization reviewer?

Insurance Utilization Reviewers are professionals who evaluate healthcare services to determine if they are medically necessary and covered by insurance policies. They review patient records, treatment plans, and insurance guidelines to ensure that the care provided aligns with established criteria and standards. Their work helps control healthcare costs, prevent unnecessary treatments, and ensure patients receive appropriate care. Utilization reviewers often communicate with healthcare providers and insurance companies to support or deny coverage decisions.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance utilization reviewer, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Insurance Utilization Reviewer, you need a solid understanding of medical terminology, healthcare regulations, and insurance processes, usually supported by a clinical background or relevant certification. Familiarity with utilization review software, electronic health records (EHRs), and coding systems like ICD-10 and CPT is often required. Strong analytical thinking, attention to detail, and effective communication skills help reviewers assess medical necessity and coordinate with healthcare providers. These skills ensure accurate, efficient case evaluations and compliance with policies, which are crucial for optimizing patient care and managing healthcare costs.

What are some common challenges faced by insurance utilization reviewers, and how can they be addressed?

One of the primary challenges Insurance Utilization Reviewers face is balancing the need to adhere to strict insurance guidelines while advocating for appropriate patient care. Reviewers often handle high caseloads and must make timely decisions based on complex medical records, which requires strong attention to detail and up-to-date knowledge of coverage policies. Effective communication with healthcare providers and insurance representatives is also crucial to resolve discrepancies and ensure approvals. Staying organized, continuously updating clinical knowledge, and leveraging support from the utilization review team can help manage these challenges successfully.

What is the difference between Insurance Utilization Reviewer vs Insurance Claims Processor?

AspectInsurance Utilization ReviewerInsurance Claims Processor
Primary RoleReview medical necessity and appropriateness of services for insurance coverageProcess and review insurance claims for payment and accuracy
Required CredentialsOften requires healthcare or insurance certifications, such as RHIT or CPCTypically requires claims processing or insurance certifications, like CPC or CPC-H
Work EnvironmentHealthcare settings, insurance companies, or third-party administratorsInsurance companies, healthcare providers, or claims processing centers
Industry UsageCommonly employed in health insurance and managed careWidely used across health, auto, and property insurance sectors

The main difference is that Insurance Utilization Reviewers focus on evaluating the medical necessity of services, while Insurance Claims Processors handle the administrative processing of claims. Both roles require insurance-related certifications and are integral to the insurance industry, but they serve distinct functions in the claims and coverage review process.

What cities near Madison, WI are hiring for Insurance Utilization Reviewer jobs?

Cities near Madison, WI with the most Insurance Utilization Reviewer job openings:

Clinical Reviewer - Portland, Oregon

Comagine Health

Oregon, WI โ€ข On-site

$75 - $90/hr

Other

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement, PTO

Posted 4 days ago


Key responsibilities

  • Review clinical documentation to substantiate medical necessity and appropriateness for requested services

  • Perform initial and continued stay reviews using standardized, evidence-based criteria

  • Document utilization review determinations accurately and timely in designated systems


Job description

If you are unable to complete this application due to a disability, contact this employer to ask for an accommodation or an alternative application process.

Clinical Reviewer - Portland, Oregon

5 days ago Requisition ID: 1126

Salary Range: $75,000.00 To $90,000.00 Annually

Are you passionate about improving access to behavioral health services in the community? Do you enjoy using your clinical expertise to evaluate needs, support care decisions, and help individuals receive the right services at the right time?

In this role, you will review clinical documentation to determine medical necessity and appropriateness of services, complete functional needs assessments that evaluate how mental health symptoms impact daily living, and support service coordination that connects children, youth, and adults to in-home and community-based care. You will manage referrals, follow-ups, reviews, and assessments within an electronic medical record system; apply evidence-based criteria to utilization management reviews; document clinical determinations; provide subject matter expertise to stakeholders; support quality activities and audits; and travel for in-person assessments as needed across your assigned region.

If you are someone who demonstrates strong clinical judgment, builds trusting relationships with members and partners, and effectively manages a high-volume workload while meeting timelines, we encourage you to apply. If you bring a collaborative mindset, accountability in your work, curiosity to ask questions and learn, and comfort using technology to navigate systems and documentation, you will be well-positioned for success on this team. This is a remote position based in Oregon and travel is required throughout the Portland, Oregon and surrounding areas.

Why Comagine Health?

Comagine Health is a national, mission-driven, nonprofit organization that has engaged in health care quality consulting and quality improvement services for more than 50 years.

We are leaders in assisting front-line providers and engaging health care partners to improve care delivery and patient outcomes.

Our talented remote workforce spans the country and plays a vital role in our success. We go beyond merely providing a remote work option; we support and embrace it. We offer opportunities to make a difference from anywhere in the U.S. and enjoy better work-life balance. An annual stipend gives you the freedom to enhance your workspace with options that suit your needs.

We believe in an environment that allows you to thrive both personally and professionally. Thatโ€™s why we offer benefits that include:

  • Medical, dental and vision insurance
  • Paid time off for vacation, illness, and volunteering
  • Retirement savings plan with employer contribution
  • Paid parental leave.
  • And much more!
You Have (Required Qualifications)
  • Current, active, unrestricted clinical licensure as required by the Oregon contract (e.g., behavioral health licensure such as LCSW, LPC, LCPC)
  • 3 years of clinical (direct patient care) experience; behavioral health preferred

Candidates must reside in Oregon, have personal transportation, and ability to travel. Valid Driver License and Proof of Auto Insurance are required.

You May Have (Desired Qualifications)
  • Experience with Medicaid
  • Knowledge of the Oregon behavioral health system of care
  • 2 years of utilization review or other medical management experience
  • 2 years of full-time substance use disorder and/or behavioral health disorder experience
  • Clinical documentation review expertise, including use of the Oregon Health Plan Prioritized List of Health Services and InterQual
  • Strong organizational skills and ability to manage multiple tasks in a team environment
  • Excellent oral and written communication skills
  • Strong interpersonal and problem-solving skills
  • Proficiency with MS Office Suite and familiarity with database software
  • Ability to apply clinical review criteria, policies, and guidelines to determine medical necessity
  • Ability to document utilization review determinations accurately and timely in designated systems
  • Capability to provide clinical and utilization review subject matter expertise and respond to stakeholder questions or concerns
In this Role, You Will
  • Review clinical documentation to substantiate medical necessity and appropriateness for requested services
  • Perform initial and continued stay reviews using standardized, evidence-based criteria to ensure services align with individualized behavioral health needs
  • Apply clinical review criteria, organizational policies, guidelines, and screening tools to determine medical necessity of healthcare services
  • Document utilization review determinations accurately and timely in designated systems
  • Consult with physician or practitioner reviewers when cases do not meet clinical review criteria
  • Refer cases to other clinicians when appropriate
  • Provide clinical and utilization review subject matter expertise and respond to stakeholder questions or concerns
  • Support quality assurance activities, audits, and other program support as assigned
  • Provide guidance or oversight to non-clinical staff performing support activities, as appropriate
  • Perform other duties as assigned
  • Full-Time
  • Reliable, secure internet connection required
  • Must maintain licensure eligibility for assigned state contract
Equal Opportunity Employer

Comagine Health is an equal opportunity employer and is committed to creating a diverse, equitable, and inclusive workplace.

Physical Requirements & Work Environment

This position is primarily remote and performed in a home-based setting, requiring reliable internet access and a workspace free from significant distractions. The role involves frequent use of computers, phones, and virtual communication tools. Employees must be able to sit for extended periods, communicate effectively.

Some positions may require operating a motor vehicle for business purposes; in such cases, employees must maintain a valid driverโ€™s license and meet the organizationโ€™s driving eligibility requirements. Occasional travel may be required for meetings, training, or other work-related events.

Reasonable accommodations will be provided to enable individuals with disabilities to perform essential functions.

#J-18808-Ljbffr