ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Agent Base Pay Jobs in Milwaukee, WI (NOW HIRING)

StaffMyAgency LLC

INSURANCE AGENT TRAINEE

Grafton, WI · On-site

$100K/yr

We will provide full one-on-one training with sales, customer service, insurance knowledge, and ... Base Pay + Commission! Responsibilities: * Provide quotes, pricing, and other information to ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

People also search for

All JobsInsurance Agent Base Pay JobsInsurance Agent Base Pay Jobs in Milwaukee, WI

Insurance Agent Base Pay information

See Milwaukee, WI salary details

$24.6K

$64.1K

$119.7K

How much do insurance agent base pay jobs pay per year?

As of May 28, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance agent base pay in Milwaukee, WI is $64,062.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $43,800.00 and $75,900.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an Insurance Agent, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Insurance Agent, you need strong sales abilities, knowledge of insurance products and regulations, and often a state insurance license. Familiarity with customer relationship management (CRM) software and quoting systems is typically required. Excellent interpersonal communication, active listening, and problem-solving skills help agents build trust and tailor solutions for clients. These skills are crucial for meeting sales targets, ensuring client satisfaction, and maintaining compliance in a competitive industry.

What are some common challenges insurance agents face when working on a base pay structure?

Insurance agents working on a base pay structure often encounter challenges such as balancing the security of a consistent salary with the motivation to exceed sales targets for additional commissions. Another common challenge is managing a robust client pipeline while maintaining high-quality customer service, as performance is often closely monitored. Agents must also stay updated on changing insurance products and regulations, which can require ongoing training and adaptability. Success in the role often depends on strong interpersonal skills, persistence, and the ability to work both independently and as part of a sales team.

What is the base pay for an insurance agent?

The base pay for an insurance agent refers to the fixed salary or hourly wage that an agent receives, excluding commissions or bonuses. This amount can vary widely depending on the employer, location, and level of experience. In the United States, the average base salary for insurance agents typically ranges from $35,000 to $50,000 per year, though some entry-level positions may start lower and experienced agents can earn more. Many insurance agents also earn commissions based on the policies they sell, which can significantly increase their total compensation.

What is the difference between Insurance Agent Base Pay vs Insurance Broker Base Pay?

AspectInsurance Agent Base PayInsurance Broker Base Pay
Required CredentialsLicensing, state-specific insurance licensesLicensing, state-specific insurance licenses
Work EnvironmentAgency offices, direct client interactionsIndependent or agency settings, client consultations
Employer & Industry UsageInsurance companies, agenciesIndependent, brokerage firms, agencies
Common Search & ComparisonYesYes

Insurance agent base pay typically refers to the fixed salary or hourly wage earned by agents working for insurance companies or agencies. Insurance brokers, while similar, often operate independently or through brokerage firms, earning commissions alongside any base pay. The main difference lies in their employment structure and client relationships, but both roles require similar licensing and work in comparable environments.

What are popular job titles related to Insurance Agent Base Pay jobs in Milwaukee, WI? For Insurance Agent Base Pay jobs in Milwaukee, WI, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Insurance Agent Base Pay jobs in Milwaukee, WI look for? The top searched job categories for Insurance Agent Base Pay jobs in Milwaukee, WI are:
What cities near Milwaukee, WI are hiring for Insurance Agent Base Pay jobs? Cities near Milwaukee, WI with the most Insurance Agent Base Pay job openings:
Insurance Agent Base Pay jobs near you
Insurance Agent (Base salary + Uncapped commissions)

Insurance Agent (Base salary + Uncapped commissions)

Comparion Insurance Agency

Milwaukee, WI • Hybrid

Full-time

Medical, Retirement, PTO

Posted 10 days ago

Job description

Description

Comparion Insurance Agency is hiring self-motivated, relationship-driven professionals for a rewarding outside sales career. This role offers autonomy and flexibility to build your career, grow your earnings, and make a meaningful impact by helping protect individuals and families with auto, home, life, and specialty insurance.

Backed by a Fortune 100 company, you'll receive hands-on training, resources, and team support to help you succeed - no prior insurance experience required.

This role is open in Colorado, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa, and Nebraska and requires an in-office presence 3-4 days per week, Monday through Friday.

Description

What you'll do:

  • Sell auto, home, life, and related insurance products using a consultative, needs-based approach.
  • Build and maintain a book of business through referrals, networking, and community engagement as part of your outside sales efforts.
  • Identify prospective customers using established lead methodologies and relationship-driven outreach.
  • Accurately document customer interactions and handle sensitive information with integrity and confidentiality.
  • Use insurance sales technology, relationship management tools, and multi-carrier platforms to deliver tailored insurance solutions.
  • Participate in training, coaching, and performance incentives to continuously improve sales results.

What We Offer:

  • Unlimited commission and renewal income - potential for earnings growth over time.
  • Full-time employment with benefits from day one, including health insurance, generous 401(k) match, and paid time off.
  • Paid training, licensing support, and ongoing development.
  • Autonomy to embrace your entrepreneurial spirit and structure your time your way.
  • Flexible work structure (hybrid office, field, and remote based on what your day requires).
  • Supportive team culture with mentorship and long-term career paths.
External Qualifications

Who We're Looking For:

Day One Skills & Traits

  • Self-motivated and accountable - you take ownership of your work and results.
  • Reliable and responsive - you follow through and do what you say you'll do.
  • Professional and trustworthy - you handle customer information with care and integrity.
  • Relationship-focused - you enjoy helping others and building long-term trust.
  • Outgoing - you're comfortable talking with people and explaining options clearly.
  • Tech savvy - you're able to learn and use technology and digital tools with ease.
  • Calm under pressure - you stay composed in a fast-paced, customer-focused environment.

Preferred Qualifications

  • Experience in customer-facing roles like retail, hospitality, service, operations, logistics, banking, account management, or sales.
  • Basic understanding of sales conversations, including handling common customer questions or objections.
  • Experience managing multiple accounts, clients, or priorities simultaneously.
  • Exposure to consultative selling, negotiation, or regulated industries.

You will be required to obtain relevant licenses upon being hired.

 

Build a career for yourself, not by yourself. Launch a rewarding insurance sales career today.

About Us

Pay Philosophy: The typical starting salary range for this role is determined by a number of factors including skills, experience, education, certifications and location. The full salary range for this role reflects the competitive labor market value for all employees in these positions across the national market and provides an opportunity to progress as employees grow and develop within the role. Some roles at Liberty Mutual have a corresponding compensation plan which may include commission and/or bonus earnings at rates that vary based on multiple factors set forth in the compensation plan for the role.

In 2022, Comparion Insurance Agency was created to transition former Liberty Mutual exclusive agents to an agency that delivers a unique value proposition to carriers with over 2,000 agents in approximately 180 cities in 44 states. We offer customers 50 insurance companies with product breadth including auto, home, life, pet, renters, umbrella, jewelry and much more. We use our scale to deliver a first-rate customer experience through consultative insurance experts located in their communities.

Our Leadership team has over 200 years of cumulative insurance experience. At Comparion, we have a philosophy of staying close to our customers and agents, so sales leadership is located throughout the country in our larger storefronts. Comparion is owned and backed by Liberty Mutual Group, a Fortune 100 company, founded in 1912

Liberty Mutual is an equal opportunity employer. We will not tolerate discrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, religion, age, disability, veteran's status, pregnancy, genetic information or on any basis prohibited by federal, state or local law.  Fair Chance Notices

  • California
  • Los Angeles Incorporated
  • Los Angeles Unincorporated
  • Philadelphia
  • San Francisco
Employment Type: FULL_TIME

Apply