ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Fill In Bartender Jobs in Sheboygan, WI (NOW HIRING)

The Osthoff Resort

Bartender

Elkhart Lake, WI

Bartender Job Purpose Provide timely and excellent beverage service to our guests while fostering a ... Be available to fill in as needed to ensure the smooth and efficient operation of the restaurant as ...

The Osthoff Resort

Bartender

Elkhart Lake, WI · On-site

Bartender Job Purpose Provide timely and excellent beverage service to our guests while fostering a ... Be available to fill in as needed to ensure the smooth and efficient operation of the restaurant as ...

All JobsFill In Bartender JobsFill In Bartender Jobs in Sheboygan, WI

Fill In Bartender information

See Sheboygan, WI salary details

$5

$15

$34

How much do fill in bartender jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 15, 2026, the average hourly pay for fill in bartender in Sheboygan, WI is $15.85, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $9.57 and $17.98 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a fill in bartender?

Fill in bartenders are professional bartenders who temporarily cover shifts when regular staff are unavailable due to illness, vacations, or other reasons. They are expected to quickly adapt to different bar environments, work with various teams, and provide consistent drink service to customers. Fill in bartenders must possess strong bartending skills, excellent customer service abilities, and flexibility to work varying hours, often on short notice. Their role is crucial in ensuring smooth bar operations and maintaining customer satisfaction during staff shortages.

What skills and qualifications are needed to thrive as a fill in bartender?

To thrive as a Fill In Bartender, you need a solid understanding of drink recipes, bar operations, and customer service, typically supported by prior bartending experience and, in some areas, a responsible beverage service certification. Familiarity with point-of-sale (POS) systems, bar tools, and inventory management software is important. Excellent communication, adaptability, and the ability to stay calm under pressure help Fill In Bartenders quickly integrate with new teams and clientele. These skills ensure smooth bar operations, customer satisfaction, and seamless transitions when covering shifts in different venues.

What is the difference between Fill In Bartender vs Barback?

AspectFill In BartenderBarback
Primary RoleServes drinks, interacts with customers, handles cashAssists bartenders by restocking supplies and cleaning
Work EnvironmentFront-of-house, customer-facingBack-of-house, support role
CredentialsBasic bartending knowledge, possibly alcohol service permitNo specific credentials required

Fill In Bartenders focus on serving customers directly, while Barbacks support bartenders behind the scenes. Both roles are essential in bar operations, but Fill In Bartenders are more customer-facing, whereas Barbacks handle supply and cleanliness tasks to ensure smooth service.

What challenges do fill in bartenders face, and how can they prepare for success in different bar environments?

Fill-in bartenders often encounter the challenge of adapting quickly to new work environments, unfamiliar POS systems, and diverse drink menus. To succeed, it's important to be adaptable, communicate proactively with the regular staff, and review the bar's menu and house policies before each shift. Developing strong organizational skills and a friendly, professional attitude helps build rapport with both coworkers and customers, ensuring smooth service even in fast-paced settings.

What are popular job titles related to Fill In Bartender jobs in Sheboygan, WI?

For Fill In Bartender jobs in Sheboygan, WI, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Fill In Bartender jobs in Sheboygan, WI look for?

The top searched job categories for Fill In Bartender jobs in Sheboygan, WI are:

What cities near Sheboygan, WI are hiring for Fill In Bartender jobs?

Cities near Sheboygan, WI with the most Fill In Bartender job openings:

Fill In Bartender jobs near you
Infographic showing various Fill In Bartender job openings in Sheboygan, WI as of June 2026, with employment types broken down into 22% Full Time, 11% Part Time, and 67% Contract. Highlights an 100% Physical job distribution, with an average salary of $32,971 per year, or $15.9 per hour.

Bartender

The Osthoff Resort

Elkhart Lake, WI

Full-time, Part-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement

Re-posted 9 days ago

Job description

Bartender
Job Purpose
Provide timely and excellent beverage service to our guests while fostering a relaxing and fun atmosphere. Assist co-workers in offering the best experiences possible to restaurant guests, supporting the AAA Four Diamond brand expectation.
**Part-time and full-time year-round positions available!
Duties and Responsibilities
  • Promptly greet guests
  • Create bonds with locals and regulars
    • Learn the names and personally recognize our regulars
  • Complete Steps of Service for Bartenders
  • Promote The Osthoff Resort’s service principle by example—respond to/resolve guest inquiries, complaints or concerns in a courteous, timely and efficient manner. Make sure to inform a team leader of any problems.
  • Prepare drinks consistent with the restaurant’s standard drink recipes
  • Maintain bar in an attractive and functional manner to support efficient drink preparations and promotions of beverages
  • Be knowledgeable about beverage products to assist guests with choices
  • Maintain cleanliness in all areas of the bar
    • Counters, sinks, utensils, shelves and storage areas, and surrounding areas to the bar
  • Report all equipment problems and bar maintenance issues to restaurant manager
  • Assist in the checklists at the beginning/end of each shift with the team
    • Including polishing, cleaning, and prepping
    • Restocking and replenishment of bar inventory and supplies
  • Complete proper end-of-day reports
    • Sales Reports, Financial Reports, Tip Reports
  • Be available to fill in as needed to ensure the smooth and efficient operation of the restaurant as directed by the restaurant manager or immediate supervisor
  • All other duties as assigned
Qualifications
  • Education: High School Diploma
  • Must be 18 years of age
  • Have Bartending License
  • Strong customer/ guest service skills
  • Have working knowledge of beer, wine and liquor and common drink recipes
  • Possess basic math skills and the ability to handle money and operate the POS
  • Be able to work in a standing position for long periods of time
  • Must possess a positive attitude as a contributor to a diverse work environment
  • Ability to exhibit a cheerful demeanor towards guests and other team members
  • Must have an outgoing, cheerful, and fun personality along with a professional attitude
  • Must have the willingness to go above and beyond what is expected to create meaningful guest experiences
  • Ability to take care of customers’ needs while following company procedures
  • Be able to work and multi-task in a fast-paced environment
  • Possess great time management skills, with the ability to think on the spot
  • Ability to learn quickly and accurately
Why Work at the Osthoff Resort?
The Osthoff Resort’s mission is to deliver the best Midwest resort experience to our guests. In order to do this, we are aways striving to create a positive and supportive work environment where our team members can thrive. Enjoy competitive pay and great benefits including medical, dental, and vision, 401(k) with company matching, resort-wide discounts, and more! We offer flexible scheduling to fit your lifestyle because we value work-life balance and know that time with family and friends is just as important as a rewarding career. At The Osthoff Resort, you're not just a part of our team--you're a part of our family. Come grow with us and love where you work!

The Osthoff Resort is an Equal Employment Opportunity Employer.
About Us
At The Osthoff Resort, located in the heart of Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin, we pride ourselves on providing an unforgettable experience for our guests. Nestled along the pristine shores of the lake, our resort offers a luxurious yet inviting atmosphere with world-class accommodation, exceptional dining, and a range of leisure activities. With a focus on personalized service and creating lasting memories, The Osthoff Resort is a cherished destination for those seeking relaxation, adventure, and a true Wisconsin getaway. Join our team and be part of a dedicated, passionate group of professionals committed to delivering outstanding hospitality in one of the most beautiful locations in the state.

Apply