ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Day Shift Supervisor Jobs in Rochester, NY (NOW HIRING)

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Penfield, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Webster, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Webster, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Webster, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Penfield, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Webster, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Webster, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Webster, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Webster, NY

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Penfield, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Pet Supplies Plus

Store Shift Supervisor

Rochester, NY · On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will ... Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include: * Partnering with store team leaders to learn and ...

Applegreen

Shift Supervisor- Burger King

Le Roy, NY · On-site

$13.75 - $17.50/hr

Shift Supervisor What We Do At Applegreen, we Refresh Travelers on their Journey . Applegreen USA ... Available to work a flexible schedule including days, nights, weekends, and holidays. * Maintain ...

previous pagenext page

Showing results 21-40

All JobsDay Shift Supervisor JobsDay Shift Supervisor Jobs in Rochester, NY

Day Shift Supervisor information

See Rochester, NY salary details

$9

$16

$21

How much do day shift supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 21, 2026, the average hourly pay for day shift supervisor in Rochester, NY is $16.50, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $14.23 and $18.03 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a day shift supervisor?

Day shift supervisors are professionals responsible for overseeing operations and staff during daytime working hours in various industries such as manufacturing, retail, or hospitality. They ensure that daily tasks are completed efficiently, employees follow company policies, and any issues are addressed promptly. Their duties often include scheduling, training, quality control, and reporting to upper management. By maintaining smooth workflow and staff motivation, day shift supervisors play a crucial role in achieving organizational goals.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a day shift supervisor, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Day Shift Supervisor, you need strong leadership abilities, time management skills, and experience in staff coordination, often supported by a relevant associate or bachelor's degree. Familiarity with workforce management software, scheduling tools, and safety compliance systems is typically required. Excellent communication, conflict resolution, and problem-solving skills help you motivate teams and address workplace challenges effectively. These skills and qualities are crucial for maintaining productivity, ensuring smooth operations, and fostering a positive work environment during day shifts.

What are some common challenges faced by a day shift supervisor and how can they be effectively managed?

Day Shift Supervisors often face challenges such as balancing production targets with quality standards, managing diverse teams, and addressing unexpected staffing or operational issues. Effective supervisors stay proactive by maintaining clear communication, fostering teamwork, and using strong organizational skills to prioritize tasks. Regularly checking in with team members, anticipating workflow bottlenecks, and collaborating with other departments (like HR or maintenance) are key strategies for managing these challenges and ensuring a smooth shift.

What is the difference between Day Shift Supervisor vs Production Line Lead?

AspectDay Shift SupervisorProduction Line Lead
CredentialsHigh school diploma; some roles prefer certifications in safety or managementHigh school diploma; experience in manufacturing often preferred
Work EnvironmentManufacturing plants, warehouses, or factories during daytime hoursFactory or production floor, overseeing assembly lines during shifts
ResponsibilitiesSupervises staff, ensures safety compliance, manages daily operationsCoordinates production activities, monitors line performance, reports issues

The Day Shift Supervisor and Production Line Lead roles share similar environments and credentials, focusing on overseeing manufacturing operations during daytime hours. The supervisor typically has broader managerial responsibilities, while the lead concentrates on production processes and line performance. Both roles are essential for efficient manufacturing workflows and are often searched together by those seeking supervisory or lead positions in production settings.

What are the most commonly searched types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Rochester, NY?

The most popular types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Rochester, NY are:

What cities near Rochester, NY are hiring for Day Shift Supervisor jobs?

Cities near Rochester, NY with the most Day Shift Supervisor job openings:

Day Shift Supervisor jobs near you
Infographic showing various Day Shift Supervisor job openings in Rochester, NY as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 68% Full Time, 27% Part Time, and 4% Contract. Highlights an 95% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 4% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $34,312 per year, or $16.5 per hour.

Store Shift Supervisor

Pet Supplies Plus

Penfield, NY • On-site

$17.50 - $18.50/hr

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, PTO

Re-posted 17 days ago

Pet Supplies Plus rating

5.1

Company rating: 5.1 out of 10

Based on 386 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

583rd of 734 rated retailers

Job description

Overview
Do 4-pawed friends make you smile? Do you enjoy cool pet products that make tails wag? So do we! If you're a paws-on leader of the pack who believes any dog can learn new tricks, then come work in our neighborhood!
Responsibilities/Qualifications
As Store Shift Supervisor at Pet Supplies Plus, you're pawsitively passionate about people and their pets. Providing exceptional, neighborly service at every opportunity during your work day, you will:
  • assist a neighbor in choosing the perfect toy for a lab who loves to fetch
  • stop to greet weekly regular Bruno the Chihuahua when he comes in with his human mom
  • show a fourth grader how to test the water in his fish tank
  • set an example for the other team members in delivering fantastic neighborly service
  • assist the store's team leaders by reinforcing the daily operational procedures and performance expectation
  • ...all while engaging with PSP neighbors and smiling in the face of puppy breath. Are you awesome? No, you are more than that. You are PAWsome!*

Shift Supervisor* key responsibilities include:
  • Partnering with store team leaders to learn and reinforce the PSP standards and daily management routines that make your store the favorite pet store in the neighborhood.
  • Providing leadership coverage and covers management functions up to four times a week when team leaders are offsite.
  • Adhering to operational policies and procedures (cleanliness, animal care, safety and security) that ensure exceptional service is provided to our neighbors.
  • Learning and performing back office procedures - like making signs, updating price changes, and imputing cashier records - to comply with standards and expectations.
  • Involvement in store recruiting, onboarding and team member development.
  • Communicating opportunities to improve community engagement or store performance to the team leaders.
  • Act as store team members when they're not acting as the manager-on-duty or learning operational tasks.
  • Willingness to perform nail trims on our furry friends.

PAWsome Shift Supervisor candidates will have:
  • A high school diploma or GED.
  • 2+ years of retail experience.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Office.
  • Strong sales and customer service skills are a must.
  • Ability to operate all equipment, including a forklift, to run the store is important, as well as the abiilty to climb ladders, bend, kneel, and lift up to 50 pounds (that cat litter can be heavy!).
  • Ability to work flexible schedules, have reliable transportation, and must pass the drug screening (where allowed by law) and be 18 years or older

Why Us:
  • Employee Discounts
  • Flexible Schedules
  • Pay Increases & Pet Care Training Programs
  • Promotion From Within Culture
  • Medical, Dental & Vision Plans (Full-Time)
  • Health Savings & Flexible Spending Accounts
  • Paid Time Off (Full-Time)

About Company
Pet Supplies Plus is focused on making it easier to get better products for your pet. With 770+ locations in 44 states, the stores have a streamlined design making it easy to navigate a wide assortment of natural foods, hard goods and pet services. Friendly, knowledgeable staff get to know each pet and their owner by name and provide playful store experiences to remind them just how fun it is to own a pet. Pet Supplies Plus stores are large enough to house an incredible variety of food and equipment, yet small enough to still feel neighborly.
Pet Supplies Plus is ranked No. 31 overall in Entrepreneur Magazine's 2026 Franchise 500® list and is the Top Full-Service Pet Supplies Franchise for its exceptional performance in areas including financial strength and stability, growth rate and system size. For more information, please visit www.petsuppliesplus.com.
EOE STATEMENT
We provide equal employment opportunities to all applicants for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, or genetics. In addition to federal law requirements, the company complies with applicable state and local laws governing nondiscrimination in employment in every location in which the company has facilities. This policy applies to all terms and conditions of employment.
Min
USD $17.50/Hr.
Max
USD $18.50/Hr.

What Pet Supplies Plus employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Apply