ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Controller Jobs in Lancaster, NY (NOW HIRING)

BMW Management Co. LLC

Controller

Williamsville, NY · Hybrid

Overview BMW Management Company is seeking a Controller with a strong public accounting tax background to oversee all tax compliance for its real estate portfolio and Family Office while assuming ...

MODERN DISPOSAL SERVICES.

Controller

Lewiston, NY · On-site

The Controller plays a key leadership role in managing a complex, asset-intensive, multi-location environment involving fleet accounting, disposal operations, route profitability, cost accounting ...

Robert Half

Controller

Tonawanda, NY · On-site

The Controller will play a key part in maintaining financial integrity while helping leadership make informed business decisions. Responsibilities: * Direct daily accounting activities to ensure ...

Robert Half

Controller

Depew, NY · On-site

We are looking for an experienced Controller to oversee core financial activities and support sound decision-making for the business in Depew, New York. This position plays a central role in managing ...

Parent Network

Controller

Buffalo, NY · On-site

Company Description Non - profit Controller Parent Network of WNY, a nonprofit in Buffalo that serves families of special needs individuals, is in search of a Controller to join its management team ...

Acara Solutions

Controller

Buffalo, NY · On-site +1

$120K - $130K/yr

Controller Location: Buffalo, NY Employment Type: Direct Hire Compensation: $120,000 - $130,000 Schedule: Hybrid Why You'll Love Working Here: Our client is a fast-growing holding company that is ...

W3Global Inc.

Assistant Controller

Buffalo, NY

$60K - $80K/yr

Controller Location: Buffalo, NY Position Summary Client is seeking a detail-oriented and motivated Assistant Controller to support the Controller in managing the firm's accounting operations and ...

Robert Half

Assistant Controller

Getzville, NY · On-site

We are looking for an Assistant Controller to support core accounting and reporting activities in Getzville, New York. This role focuses on maintaining accurate financial records, coordinating ...

StaffBuffalo

Assistant Controller

Getzville, NY · Hybrid

$70K - $110K/yr

Assistant Controller Overview: StaffBuffalo is working with a dynamic, global organization to hire an Assistant Controller in Getzville, NY. This is an outstanding opportunity for an experienced ...

Lactalis

Assistant Controller

Buffalo, NY · On-site

$75K - $85K/yr

The Assistant Logistics Controller reports to the Logistics Controller. The position is accountable for assisting the logistics accounting department. Ensures that the entries recorded in the general ...

Lactalis USA

Assistant Controller

Buffalo, NY · Hybrid

$75K - $85K/yr

The Assistant Logistics Controller reports to the Logistics Controller. The position is accountable for assisting the logistics accounting department. Ensures that the entries recorded in the general ...

Washington Mills

Plant Controller

Tonawanda, NY · On-site

$110K - $140K/yr

Plant Controller Position type: Full-Time, Salaried Location: Tonawanda, NY Ask Yourself This... Are you an accounting expert who loves to deep dive into all aspects of finance? Are you looking for ...

Sheridan HR

Cost Controller

Buffalo, NY · On-site

The Cost Controller will ensure accurate financial records, clean balance sheets, and reconciled P&Ls while driving operational analysis and project cost control. You'll help steer budgets, track ...

Robert Half

Financial Controller

Depew, NY · On-site

$38 - $44/hr

We are looking for a Financial Controller to join our team in Depew, New York in a contract capacity with the potential to become permanent. This position is well suited for a detail-oriented finance ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsController JobsController Jobs in Lancaster, NY

Controller information

See Lancaster, NY salary details

$52.7K

$114.6K

$168.3K

How much do controller jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 28, 2026, the average yearly pay for controller in Lancaster, NY is $114,573.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $93,000.00 and $132,800.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a controller?

A controller is high-level accounting position in a firm or company. They often report directly to the CFO (Chief Financial Officer) and are responsible for budgets, audits, and financial reports, as well as ensuring the company complies with all tax codes and regulations.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a controller, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Controller, you need a strong background in accounting principles, financial analysis, and regulatory compliance, typically supported by a bachelor's degree in accounting or finance and often a CPA certification. Proficiency with ERP systems, advanced Excel, and financial reporting software is essential for managing complex financial data. Exceptional organizational skills, attention to detail, and effective communication set top Controllers apart. These skills and qualities ensure accurate financial oversight, compliance, and strategic decision-making for organizational success.

What are some common challenges controllers face when managing financial reporting and compliance?

Controllers often encounter challenges in ensuring the accuracy and timeliness of financial reports, particularly when juggling complex transactions or multiple entities. Staying current with evolving accounting standards and regulatory requirements can also be demanding, as it requires continual learning and adaptation. Additionally, Controllers must coordinate closely with cross-functional teams, such as auditors and department heads, to address discrepancies and streamline processes, making strong communication and problem-solving skills essential.

What is the difference between Controller vs Bookkeeper?

AspectControllerBookkeeper
CredentialsTypically requires a bachelor's degree in accounting, finance, or related field; CPA or CMA certifications are commonUsually requires a high school diploma or associate degree; certifications are less common
Work EnvironmentWorks in corporate finance departments, overseeing accounting teamsWorks in small businesses or accounting firms, handling day-to-day transaction recording
ResponsibilitiesFinancial reporting, budgeting, internal controls, and strategic financial planningRecording financial transactions, maintaining ledgers, and reconciling accounts

The Controller and Bookkeeper roles differ mainly in scope and seniority. Controllers oversee financial strategies and reporting, requiring advanced credentials and experience. Bookkeepers focus on recording daily transactions and maintaining accurate records. While both are essential for financial management, Controllers have broader responsibilities and higher qualifications, often managing teams and ensuring compliance.

Is a controller a high position?

A controller is a senior management role responsible for overseeing an organization’s accounting and financial reporting. It is generally considered a high-level position, often reporting to the CFO and requiring extensive financial expertise and certifications such as CPA or CMA.
More about Controller jobs

What are popular job titles related to Controller jobs in Lancaster, NY?

For Controller jobs in Lancaster, NY, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What cities near Lancaster, NY are hiring for Controller jobs?

Cities near Lancaster, NY with the most Controller job openings:

Controller jobs near you
Infographic showing various Controller job openings in Lancaster, NY as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 100% Full Time. Highlights an 100% In-person job distribution, with an average salary of $114,573 per year, or $55.1 per hour.

Controller

BMW Management Co. LLC

Williamsville, NY • Hybrid

Full-time

Re-posted 7 days ago

Job description

Overview

BMW Management Company is seeking a Controller with a strong public accounting tax background to oversee all tax compliance for its real estate portfolio and Family Office while assuming responsibility for key accounting, treasury, and financial reporting functions.

This is an outstanding opportunity for a CPA who enjoys tax but is looking to broaden their experience beyond public accounting. The successful candidate will work closely with the CFO/ownership and gain valuable exposure to the financial operations of a growing real estate and Family Office organization, creating a clear path toward future senior financial leadership.

Key Responsibilities

Tax Management (Primary Focus)

  • Prepare Year End tax workpapers and coordinate with accounting firm to produce final tax returns.  Review final drafts of tax returns and ensure accuracy
  • Coordinate and manage the annual tax compliance process, with peak workloads during March/April and August through October.
  • Ensure timely, accurate, and compliant preparation and filing of all tax returns.
  • Serve as the primary internal resource for tax planning, compliance, and related matters.

Controller Responsibilities

  • Review accounting activities and financial statements to ensure accuracy and completeness.
  • Perform financial analysis and provide recommendations to management.
  • Oversee treasury functions, including cash management and banking relationships.
  • Assist with maintaining and improving accounting processes and internal controls.
  • Perform annual compliance procedures for banks and other financial institutions
  • Work closely with the CFO on financial reporting and operational initiatives
  • Other responsibilities include but not limited to assisting with annual insurance renewal, workers compensation audit, weekly payroll, etc.

Growth Opportunity

  • Gain exposure to broader financial leadership responsibilities within the organization.
  • Participate in strategic projects and, where appropriate, financial analysis related to business opportunities and investments.
  • Develop the experience necessary for future advancement into senior financial leadership roles.

Candidate Profile

Required Qualifications

  • CPA strongly preferred.
  • 6–12 years of public accounting tax experience, ideally with a regional or national CPA firm.
  • Strong technical knowledge of federal and state tax compliance.
  • Experience with pass-through entities such as partnerships, LLCs, and grantor trusts, CLATs, SLATs, etc.   Experience in real estate taxation or small business is highly desirable.
  • Excellent analytical, organizational, and communication skills.
  • Ability to work closely with others having diverse skill levels and personalities.
  • Ability to manage multiple tasks and competing priorities.
  • Take initiative and ownership over work and work in a fast paced work environment

Preferred Background

The ideal candidate is someone who has built a solid career in public accounting tax and is ready to transition into industry while expanding into accounting, treasury, and financial management. Prior Controller experience is not required. The CFO has developed efficient accounting processes and is committed to mentoring the successful candidate in the operational aspects of the role. 

Why Consider This Opportunity?

  • Unique combination of tax leadership and Controller responsibilities.
  • Direct interaction with the CFO and ownership leading to an accelerated learning curve of the real estate industry.
  • Opportunity to broaden your financial leadership experience.
  • Long-term career growth with increasing strategic responsibility.
  • Challenging work but still maintaining a work/life balance with path to partial remote work