1

Case Order Selector Jobs in Buffalo, NY (NOW HIRING)

Case Order Selector information

See Buffalo, NY salary details

$11

$17

$21

How much do case order selector jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 18, 2026, the average hourly pay for case order selector in Buffalo, NY is $17.32, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $15.82 and $18.17 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a case order selector?

Case Order Selectors are warehouse workers responsible for locating, selecting, and preparing cases of products for shipment based on customer orders. They typically use hand-held scanners and operate equipment like pallet jacks or forklifts to gather items efficiently and accurately. This role is essential in distribution centers and warehouses, ensuring that products are correctly picked, packed, and sent out on time. Attention to detail, physical stamina, and the ability to work quickly are important qualities for this position.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a case order selector, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Case Order Selector, you need physical stamina, attention to detail, and basic math skills, often with a high school diploma or equivalent. Familiarity with warehouse management systems (WMS), handheld scanners, and pallet jacks or forklifts is typically required. Strong time management, teamwork, and reliability are essential soft skills for excelling in this role. These abilities help ensure accurate, efficient order fulfillment and maintain smooth warehouse operations.

What are some common challenges faced by case order selectors, and how can they be managed effectively?

Case Order Selectors often encounter challenges such as working in fast-paced environments, meeting strict accuracy and productivity targets, and handling heavy or bulky items. These challenges can be managed by maintaining strong attention to detail, following proper lifting techniques to prevent injury, and staying organized throughout each shift. Many warehouses provide training and encourage teamwork, which helps new hires adapt quickly and improves overall efficiency. Regular communication with supervisors and coworkers also ensures that issues can be addressed promptly and collaboratively.

What is the difference between Case Order Selector vs Pallet Jack Operator?

AspectCase Order SelectorPallet Jack Operator
CredentialsBasic warehouse certifications, forklift license often preferredForklift certification usually required
Work EnvironmentWarehouse, distribution centers, often involves using RF scannersWarehouse, loading docks, operating pallet jacks
Industry UsageCommon in retail, logistics, distributionCommon in warehousing, manufacturing, shipping
Job FocusPicking, packing, and preparing ordersMoving pallets and heavy loads within warehouse

The main difference between a Case Order Selector and a Pallet Jack Operator is that the Case Order Selector primarily focuses on selecting and preparing individual cases for shipment, often using RF scanners, while the Pallet Jack Operator specializes in moving pallets and heavy loads within the warehouse using pallet jacks. Both roles are essential in warehouse operations but differ in daily tasks and equipment used.

What are popular job titles related to Case Order Selector jobs in Buffalo, NY?

For Case Order Selector jobs in Buffalo, NY, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Case Order Selector jobs in Buffalo, NY look for?

The top searched job categories for Case Order Selector jobs in Buffalo, NY are:

What cities near Buffalo, NY are hiring for Case Order Selector jobs?

Cities near Buffalo, NY with the most Case Order Selector job openings:

Apply Now! Warehouse Associate- Selectors- Varying Day and Evening Shifts

TOPS Markets

Lancaster, NY • On-site

$25.16/hr

Other

Re-posted 13 days ago


Tops Markets rating

5.4

Company rating: 5.4 out of 10

Based on 287 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

94th of 122 rated grocery stores


Job description

Warehouse Associate- Selectors- Varying Day and Evening Shifts

Lancaster, NY, US, 14086 Company: Tops Pay rate starting at: $22.15/hr training rate of pay for perishable and grocery selectors. Upon completion of training, rate of pay for perishable and grocery selectors starts at $25.16. $22.65/hr training rate of pay for freezer selectors. Upon completion of training, rate of pay for freezer selectors starts at $25.45. Rates of pay are determined by labor contract seniority.

The mission of all Tops associates is to adhere to the Tops vision of providing a friendly neighborhood store that saves the customer time and money. Tops Markets is accepting applications for current and future Selector openings. A Selector works individually selecting full case grocery/perishable/frozen items from pick slots. The selector fits these items on a pallet, plastic wraps the bundles, completed pallets, and stages for loading. A voice system is used to direct generalists to the locations where each case of product will be picked.

To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each essential duty satisfactorily. The requirements listed are representative of the knowledge, skill and/or ability required. Reasonable accommodation may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions.

Description of Work Environment: Temperature of Grocery warehouses can range from 50° to 80° Fahrenheit, a Perishable warehouse can range from 28° to 60° Fahrenheit, and a Freezer warehouse can range from -20° to -10° Fahrenheit.

If we have hiring needs and you are selected for an interview, we will contact you by phone, text or e-mail. Thank you for your interest in employment with Tops Markets.

Essential Duties and Responsibilities

A Generalist Trainee will be provided with instruction, training and safety information to be able to perform the following:

  • Ensure accuracy of work and adherence to production and safety standards.
  • Listen to the voice system to find individual items within warehouse
  • Remove full case(s) of product from storage rack and place on pallet
  • Maneuver pallet on an electric pallet jack until full or order is complete
  • Ensure item pick accuracy and safety of product to prevent damage
  • Inform supervisor of any discrepancies in case quantity and/or product description
  • Manually wrap the pallet by circling load with roll of plastic wrap until secure
  • Load bundles onto trucks with the pallet jack
  • Operate heavy equipment
  • Other duties may be assigned
Minimum Qualifications

Must be at least 18 years of age Ability to work weekends -varying shifts available Constant - standing, walking, driving, carrying, twisting, bending, seeing, hearing, and handling paperwork. Lifting of objects weighing from less than 20 lbs. to 90 lbs. Frequent- stooping, balancing, and hearing Occasional - pushing, sitting, feeling, reaching, climbing, pulling, gripping of items ranging from under 20 lbs. to over 60 lbs. Steel toed shoes are required Ability to read, write, and perform basic math functions Possess basic computer skills Possess strong communication skills GED recommended but not required 6-12 months of warehouse experience recommended but not required

Physical Requirements: Equipment Used Ride on Pallet Jack Voice System for order selection

Our Company does not discriminate against individuals on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, affection or sexual orientation, disability, age, marital status, liability for military service, status as a veteran, gender identity or expression, genetic information, pregnancy, and any other characteristic protected by applicable federal, state, or local laws. Should your hours and availability better fit the needs of another store or desired shift, we may consider your application for another location or shift.


What Tops Markets employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom