ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator Jobs in Wisconsin

Frasco, Inc.

Surveillance Investigator

Milwaukee, WI · On-site

$22 - $28/hr

Get paid to learn the ropes of fraud investigation and real-world surveillance. Frasco offers fully ... Minimum Auto Insurance Coverage: $100,000 per person, $300,000 per accident bodily injury, and $50 ...

Frasco Inc

Surveillance Investigator

Milwaukee, WI

$22 - $28/hr

Get paid to learn the ropes of fraud investigation and real-world surveillance. Frasco offers fully ... Minimum Auto Insurance Coverage: $100,000 per person, $300,000 per accident bodily injury, and $50 ...

Frasco Inc

Surveillance Investigator

Milwaukee, WI · On-site

$22 - $28/hr

Get paid to learn the ropes of fraud investigation and real-world surveillance. Frasco offers fully ... Minimum Auto Insurance Coverage: $100,000 per person, $300,000 per accident bodily injury, and $50 ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsAuto Insurance Fraud Investigator JobsAuto Insurance Fraud Investigator Jobs in Wisconsin

Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator information

See Wisconsin salary details

$15

$31

$53

How much do auto insurance fraud investigator jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 12, 2026, the average hourly pay for auto insurance fraud investigator in Wisconsin is $31.12, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $22.31 and $35.67 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator vs Claims Adjuster?

AspectAuto Insurance Fraud InvestigatorClaims Adjuster
Required CredentialsHigh school diploma or equivalent; some roles require certifications in insurance or fraud detectionHigh school diploma or equivalent; licensing or certifications may be required depending on state
Work EnvironmentOffice settings, field investigations, collaboration with law enforcementOffice-based, inspecting damages, interviewing claimants and witnesses
Employer & IndustryInsurance companies, law enforcement agencies, fraud detection firmsInsurance companies, adjusting claims for auto, home, or other policies
Common Search & ComparisonAuto Insurance Fraud Investigator vs Claims Adjuster

While both roles work within the insurance industry, Auto Insurance Fraud Investigators focus on detecting and preventing fraudulent claims, often involving investigations and law enforcement collaboration. Claims Adjusters handle the assessment and processing of legitimate claims, verifying damages and coverage. Understanding these differences helps clarify career paths and job expectations in the insurance sector.

What are some common challenges auto insurance fraud investigators face when conducting investigations?

Auto Insurance Fraud Investigators often encounter challenges such as distinguishing between genuine claims and sophisticated fraudulent schemes, managing high caseloads, and staying updated on evolving fraud tactics. They frequently collaborate with law enforcement, attorneys, and claims adjusters, requiring strong communication and analytical skills. Additionally, investigators must adhere to legal and ethical guidelines while collecting evidence, which can sometimes slow down the investigative process but is crucial for building a solid case.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an auto insurance fraud investigator?

To thrive as an Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator, you need strong analytical skills, attention to detail, and a background in criminal justice or insurance, often supported by a bachelor's degree or relevant certification. Familiarity with claims management software, data analysis tools, and investigative databases is also important. Excellent communication, critical thinking, and discretion help you conduct interviews and build cases effectively. These skills are crucial to accurately identifying fraudulent claims, protecting company assets, and upholding legal and ethical standards in the insurance industry.

What does an auto insurance fraud investigator do?

An Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator is responsible for examining suspected fraudulent claims related to automobile insurance. They gather evidence, interview claimants and witnesses, analyze documents, and collaborate with law enforcement when necessary. Their goal is to identify false or exaggerated claims, help prevent financial losses for insurance companies, and ensure that legitimate claims are paid fairly. Investigators often use surveillance, background checks, and data analysis to uncover fraudulent activity.
What are popular job titles related to Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator jobs in Wisconsin? For Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator jobs in Wisconsin, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator jobs in Wisconsin look for? The top searched job categories for Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator jobs in Wisconsin are:
Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator jobs near you
Infographic showing various Auto Insurance Fraud Investigator job openings in Wisconsin as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% Internship, 1% As Needed, 88% Full Time, 7% Part Time, and 3% Contract. Highlights an 92% In-person, 4% Hybrid, and 4% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $64,732 per year, or $31.1 per hour.

Special Agent

National Insurance Crime Bureau

Milwaukee, WI • On-site

$66K - $73K/yr

Full-time

Retirement, PTO

Posted 20 days ago

Job description

With a 110-year heritage, the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) is the nation's premier not-for-profit organization dedicated exclusively to fighting insurance fraud and crime.

NICB membership includes more than 1,200 property-casualty insurance companies, vehicle rental companies, auto auctions, vehicle finance companies, self-insured organizations and strategic partners. Beyond our membership, our more than 400 employees work with law enforcement agencies, technology experts, government officials, prosecutors, international crime-fighting organizations and the public to lead a united effort to prevent and combat insurance fraud and crime.

A career with the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) is rewarding and fulfilling to people who have the passion to play an important role in combating insurance fraud and vehicle crime. At the NICB, we know our people are our competitive advantage, and so, we offer a work atmosphere that is second to none.

Position Purpose:

This position serves as the primary NICB contact with member companies and law enforcement agencies providing advice on preventing and combating insurance related crime and fraud in their designated geographical areas. Special Agents are responsible for initiating and conducting investigations which result in the dismantlement of organized groups/rings, arrests of those involved, loss mitigations, restitution, and reduction of insurance fraud. The position functions as the investigative arm of the NICB, working in cooperation with member companies, law enforcement and other associated agencies to combat insurance related crime.

Work Arrangement and Description:

  • This is a field position which means that the individual is assigned to an Area of Responsibility (AOR) and must travel within that AOR in order to fulfill their job responsibilities. The individual will be assigned to cover the entire state of Wisconsin with a majority of the work in the Greater Milwaukee area.

Responsibilities:

  • Conducts timely and thorough, multi-claim, multi-carrier criminal investigations.
  • Collects, analyzes, and calculates relevant data for use in investigations.
  • Properly documents all phases of investigative activity.
  • Prepares summary investigative presentations for submission to law enforcement/prosecutor.
  • Represents NICB in criminal court as requested, often testifying as an expert witness.
  • Serves as liaison with member companies, law enforcement and government agencies to promote and provide the full range of NICB services.
  • Functions as a “technical” expert in fraud investigations and identifying insurance fraud schemes/claim file review.
  • Maintains membership in appropriate professional organizations.
  • Works well with others in a Task Force environment / a team player.
  • Establishes and maintains business relationships with member companies, law enforcement, regulatory agencies and vendors.
  • Provides comprehensive training to member companies and law enforcement on related insurance crime matters.
  • Identifies potential new member customers.
  • Other duties as assigned.

Requirements:

  • Bachelor’s degree or 7-10 years of equivalent experience required
  • Valid Driver’s license required
  • 3-5 years of related investigative experience required
  • Insurance industry or law enforcement experience preferred

Skills and Abilities:

  • Recognized functional expert.
  • Above average performance sustained over time.
  • Ability to interface successfully with a variety of people.
  • Ability to continually exercise discretion and independent judgment in matters of significance.
  • Ability to work independently under pressure.
  • Capacity to travel.
  • Good written and verbal communication skills.
  • High level of organization skills.
  • Sound decision making skills.
  • Operate and maintain NICB issued equipment, including the ability to drive a company vehicle.

Supervisory Responsibilities:

This position has no direct reports.

Contacts:

  • All levels of NICB employees
  • Law Enforcement and Prosecutors at all levels
  • Member Company Personnel

Environment/Physical Demands:

  • Works in an unstructured environment
  • Covers a wide geographical area with little or no direct onsite supervision.
  • Squatting, climbing, stooping
  • May be required to lift up to 25 pounds
  • Travel required
  • Must possess valid driver’s license and be able to drive a company vehicle.

Salary Range and Statement:

The salary range for this position is $66,750 to $73,330. Please keep in mind that this range represents the pay range for all positions in the job grade within which this position falls. The actual salary offer will take into account a wide range of factors including the specific requirements for this position, the candidate's geographic location, job-related skills, experience, and relevant education or training. NICB HR can share more about the specific salary range for your geographic location during the hiring process.

Benefits:

Our benefits are unparalleled! NICB offers employees a comprehensive benefits package, an attractive 401(k) plan and generous paid time off. For more information, visit https://www.nicb.org/about-nicb/careers.

The NICB is an Equal Opportunity Employer and Prohibits Discrimination and Harassment of Any Kind: NICB is committed to the principle of equal employment opportunity for all employees and to providing employees with a work environment free of discrimination and harassment. All employment decisions at the NICB are based on business needs, job requirements and individual qualifications, without regard to race, color, religion or belief, national, social or ethnic origin, sex (including pregnancy), age, physical, mental or sensory disability, sexual orientation, gender identity and/or expression, marital, civil union or domestic partnership status, past or present military service, family medical history or genetic information, family or parental status, or any other status protected by the laws or regulations in the locations where we operate.