1

Shift Supervisor Jobs in Wisconsin (NOW HIRING)

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

Earn $19-$24/hour as a Restaurant Shift Supervisor / Shift Leader at Ian's Pizza in Verona, WI . Join the team behind our legendary pizza pies and help lead one of the most unique pizza restaurant ...

Shift Supervisor

Combined Locks, WI

$15 - $18.75/hr

The Shift Supervisor is a vital part of the leadership team, fostering a culture of safety and continuous improvement while supporting 24/7 operations. This is an excellent opportunity for ...

Shift Supervisor

Appleton, WI · On-site

$17.65 - $21.28/hr

Shift Supervisor $17.65-21.28/hr Shift Supervisor Shift Supervisor Range: $17.65 - $21.28 Our Restaurant Hourly Shift Supervisors not only have an appetite for bottomless fun & compassion for our ...

Shift Supervisor

Wausau, WI

$17.65 - $21.28/hr

Shift Supervisor $17.65-21.28/hr Shift Supervisor Shift Supervisor Range: $17.65 - $21.28 Our Restaurant Hourly Shift Supervisors not only have an appetite for bottomless fun & compassion for our ...

$17-$19/hour as a Shift Supervisor at our restaurant in Milwaukee, WI! Opening in July 2026 in the Harbor District, just north of Bay View! If you are excited about being part of something new (and ...

Shift Supervisor

Germantown, WI · On-site

$15.25 - $19.25/hr

As a Shift Supervisor at MGS, you will be responsible for supervising through strategic planning to ensure the highest level of Safety, Quality, and Efficiency are being met on the assigned shift.

Shift Supervisor

Germantown, WI · On-site

$15.25 - $19.25/hr

As a Shift Supervisor at MGS, you will be responsible for supervising through strategic planning to ensure the highest level of Safety, Quality, and Efficiency are being met on the assigned shift.

Shift Supervisor

Grafton, WI · On-site

$14.75 - $18.75/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with BH Super Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be ...

Shift Supervisor

Janesville, WI

$13.25 - $17/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with R&G Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be your ...

Earn up to $18/hour Shift Supervisor: 'You are applying for work with Dawson's Slice of Life, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired ...

Shift Supervisor

Howard, WI · On-site

$14.50 - $18.50/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with R&G Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be your ...

Shift Supervisor

Appleton, WI · On-site

$14.75 - $18.50/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with R&G Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be your ...

Shift Supervisor

Kaukauna, WI · On-site

$15.25 - $19.25/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with R&G Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be your ...

Shift Supervisor

West Bend, WI · On-site

$14.50 - $18.50/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with R&G Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be your ...

Shift Supervisor

Appleton, WI · On-site

$14.75 - $18.50/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with R&G Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be your ...

Shift Supervisor

River Falls, WI · On-site

$15.25 - $19.25/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with Up North Papa Murphy's, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will ...

Shift Supervisor

West Bend, WI · On-site

$14.50 - $18.50/hr

Shift Supervisor: "You are applying for work with R&G Pizza LLC, a franchisee of Papa Murphy's, not Papa Murphy's International, Inc., or any of its affiliates. If hired, the franchisee will be your ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Shift Supervisor information

See Wisconsin salary details

$10

$16

$22

How much do shift supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of May 28, 2026, the average hourly pay for shift supervisor in Wisconsin is $16.88, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $14.57 and $18.46 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a Shift Supervisor, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Shift Supervisor, you need strong leadership, organizational skills, and experience in team management, often supported by a high school diploma or equivalent and relevant industry experience. Familiarity with scheduling software, point-of-sale systems, and inventory management tools is typically required. Exceptional communication, conflict resolution, and problem-solving abilities distinguish top performers in this role. These skills ensure smooth operations, high employee morale, and consistent achievement of business goals during each shift.

How does a Shift Supervisor typically balance overseeing team performance with handling customer issues during a busy shift?

As a Shift Supervisor, you are expected to manage both staff and customer needs simultaneously, especially during peak hours. This involves delegating tasks efficiently, monitoring employee performance, and stepping in to resolve customer concerns promptly. Successful supervisors often rely on strong communication and time-management skills to keep the team motivated while ensuring customer satisfaction. It's common to collaborate closely with other supervisors or managers to address challenges as they arise and maintain smooth shift operations.

What are shift supervisors?

Shift supervisors are team leaders responsible for overseeing operations and employees during a specific shift. They ensure that work is completed efficiently, handle any issues that arise, and maintain communication between staff and management. Shift supervisors may also be responsible for scheduling, training new employees, and ensuring company policies are followed. Their role is crucial in maintaining smooth daily operations and providing support to both employees and customers.

How much should a supervisor get paid per hour?

The hourly pay for a shift supervisor typically ranges from $12 to $25, depending on the industry, location, experience, and company size. Supervisors with additional responsibilities or certifications may earn higher wages, and pay rates often reflect the complexity of the role and the work environment.

What qualifications do you need to become a shift supervisor?

To become a shift supervisor, candidates typically need a high school diploma or equivalent, along with relevant work experience in the industry. Strong leadership, communication, and organizational skills are essential, and some employers may prefer candidates with prior supervisory or team lead experience. Certifications such as first aid or safety training can be advantageous but are not always required.

What is the difference between Shift Supervisor vs Team Leader?

AspectShift SupervisorTeam Leader
CredentialsHigh school diploma or equivalent; some roles may require certifications in safety or specific skillsHigh school diploma or equivalent; leadership or team management certifications are common
Work EnvironmentFast-paced settings like retail, hospitality, manufacturingSimilar environments, often in retail, customer service, or hospitality
Employer UsageSupervises daily operations, manages staff during shiftsLeads a team, focuses on team development and task completion

While both roles involve supervising staff and ensuring smooth operations, a Shift Supervisor typically oversees daily shift activities, focusing on operational tasks. A Team Leader emphasizes guiding and motivating team members to achieve goals. Both roles require similar credentials and work in comparable environments, but their focus areas differ slightly.

More about Shift Supervisor jobs
What are the most commonly searched types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin? The most popular types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin are:
What cities in Wisconsin are hiring for Shift Supervisor jobs? Cities in Wisconsin with the most Shift Supervisor job openings:
Shift Supervisor

Shift Supervisor

Fazoli's

Stevens Point, WI

$7.25 - $16.50/hr

Full-time

Medical, Life, PTO

Posted 16 days ago


Fazoli's rating

4.7

Company rating: 4.7 out of 10

Based on 89 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

76th of 104 rated fast food restaurants


Job description

Ever consider running a multi-million dollar business? Fazoli’s is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that!

Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place where the pasta is always hot, the breadsticks are always fresh, and the team is ready to roll? If you said "yes," then we want YOU to join our team as a Shift Supervisor at Fazoli’s!

We are proud to provide competitive benefits and pay.

We offer DAILY PAY for all hourly employees! Work today, get paid tomorrow!

Benefits:

  • Medical Benefits
  • Bonus Potential
  • Free Meals while Working*
  • Tuition Reimbursement/ GED Assistance
  • Life Insurance
  • Direct Deposit
  • Tenure Recognition
  • Referral Bonus
  • Opportunity for Advancement
  • Uniforms
  • Vacation
  • Employee Assistance Program (ComPsych)
  • Unity Care
  • Company Chaplain


Our shift Supervisors enjoy a stable environment and flexible schedules that give them the quality of life they deserve. We are currently hiring Shift Supervisors who are motivated individuals with excellent interpersonal skills, and the ability to build a team that works well together, increase profits, and provide superior service. If you have prior restaurant experience, you may qualify!

This Fazoli’s location is a part of Manna Inc.  Manna Inc. is an affiliate of several restaurant concepts founded in 1988 and based out of Louisville, KY.  Each Manna affiliate is a minority owned company that focuses and dedicates itself to fostering an environment of diversity and inclusion.

We established the Unity Care Fund, a charity funded by Manna and its employees to provide aid to employees in times of crisis.

Manna’s Women in Leadership Council is built on a set of core values and guiding principles that support our commitment to the ongoing development and growth of the women in our companies.

We believe in YOU! Employee development is a critical part of our business. We offer hourly employee development to our teammates and more than 50% of our managers come from the hourly ranks!

Job Description: Shift Supervisor at Fazoli's

Position Title: Shift Supervisor
Reports To: Restaurant Manager/ General Manager

Position Overview:

The Shift Supervisor at Fazoli’s is responsible for overseeing daily restaurant operations during their assigned shift. This role involves managing the front-line team, ensuring customer satisfaction, maintaining operational efficiency, and supporting the management team in achieving business goals. The Shift Supervisor plays a crucial role in leading by example, providing guidance to staff, and ensuring that the restaurant maintains a high standard of food quality, cleanliness, and service. This is a hands-on leadership position that requires excellent communication, problem-solving, and multitasking skills.

Key Responsibilities:

  1. Leadership & Team Supervision:

    • Supervise and lead team members during the shift, ensuring they are performing tasks effectively and efficiently.

    • Provide guidance, coaching, and feedback to team members to improve performance and foster a positive team environment.

    • Ensure the team is trained on company policies, procedures, and best practices.

    • Delegate tasks to staff based on priorities and workflow, ensuring all areas of the restaurant are covered.

  2. Customer Service:

    • Ensure an exceptional guest experience by maintaining high service standards and resolving any customer complaints or issues promptly.

    • Monitor guest satisfaction and handle any concerns, ensuring customers leave with a positive impression.

    • Lead by example in providing friendly and efficient service to all guests.

  3. Operational Efficiency:

    • Oversee the restaurant's daily operations, including food preparation, inventory management, and cleaning procedures.

    • Ensure that food is prepared to Fazoli’s quality standards and is delivered to customers in a timely manner.

    • Monitor restaurant performance during the shift, including speed of service, food quality, and cleanliness.

  4. Financial & Cash Handling:

    • Ensure accurate cash handling and register operations, including opening and closing registers, counting cash, and processing transactions.

    • Assist in managing labor costs by adjusting staffing levels as needed to meet demand.

    • Maintain adherence to company policies for handling cash, credit cards, and other forms of payment.

  5. Staffing & Scheduling:

    • Ensure that breaks, meal periods, and shifts are managed appropriately for staff.

    • Step in as needed to cover shifts or assist with additional tasks when required.


  1. Food Safety & Sanitation:

    • Ensure the restaurant is compliant with health and safety regulations, including food handling, sanitation, and cleanliness standards.

    • Monitor kitchen and dining areas to ensure that cleanliness standards are consistently maintained throughout the shift.

    • Oversee the proper storage and handling of food and supplies to prevent waste or contamination.

  2. Problem-Solving & Decision Making:

    • Make quick and effective decisions in response to operational challenges, customer issues, or staff concerns.

    • Resolve conflicts or issues that arise among team members or with customers, escalating to the Manager or Assistant Manager as needed.

  3. Communication & Reporting:

    • Communicate effectively with management, staff, and guests to ensure smooth operations.

    • Report any issues, equipment malfunctions, or significant occurrences to the Restaurant Manager.

    • Provide feedback to the management team on employee performance and operational improvements.

Skills & Qualifications:

  • Experience: Previous experience in food service, preferably in a supervisory or leadership role. A background in fast-casual or quick-service restaurants is a plus.

  • Leadership: Strong leadership and people management skills to effectively lead a team and foster a positive work environment.

  • Customer Service: Excellent customer service skills with the ability to resolve complaints and ensure customer satisfaction.

  • Communication: Clear and effective communication skills, both verbal and written, with the ability to relay information to team members and management.

  • Problem-Solving: Ability to make decisions quickly and effectively, resolving issues with minimal disruption.

  • Multitasking: Strong organizational skills with the ability to manage multiple tasks and priorities simultaneously.

  • Attention to Detail: High level of attention to detail in maintaining restaurant standards and meeting customer expectations.

Job Requirements:

  • Ability to stand for extended periods (4-8+ hours) with periodic breaks.

  • Perform repetitive motions, including frequent use of hands and arms for tasks such as chopping, stirring, carrying, and operating equipment.

  • Frequent bending, stooping, squatting, stretching, twisting, and reaching above eye level.

  • Capability to walk up and down stairs and use a step ladder as needed.

  • Occasional sitting, talking, and active listening as required by the role.

  • Ability to lift and carry up to 50 pounds regularly as part of job duties, including but not limited to food supplies, dishware, and equipment. When handling heavier loads, employees MUST use appropriate lifting equipment and/or seek assistance from a second person. 

  • Ability to move around the kitchen quickly and efficiently.

  • Compliance with food safety and sanitation regulations.


Work Environment/ Job Conditions:

  • Flexible scheduling, including nights, weekends, and holidays.

  • Work in a loud, fast-paced environment.

  • Employees may regularly work in varying temperature zones, including hot kitchen areas with stoves, ovens, grills, and fryers, as well as cold storage areas like refrigerators and freezers.

  • May involve exposure to heat, noise, and cleaning chemicals in the kitchen area.

  • Proper personal protective equipment (PPE) and training to ensure safety and comfort while handling temperature-sensitive tasks.

  • Awareness of temperature fluctuations and safe practices is essential for maintaining food safety standards and personal well-being.

  • Job duties span both indoor and outdoor settings, requiring adaptability to different environments.

  • Outdoor tasks may involve curbside delivery, trash maintenance, or ensuring a clean and welcoming exterior for guests.

  • Awareness of potential hazards such as hot surfaces, sharp objects, and wet floors.


This job description provides an overview of the responsibilities and qualifications for the Shift Supervisor position at Fazoli's. Specific duties and requirements may vary by location or role.



What Fazoli's employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom


Fazoli's logo

About Fazoli's

Sourced by ZipRecruiter

Fazoli's is a renowned restaurant chain headquartered in Lexington, KY, US. It operates mainly in the fast-casual dining industry, offering quality, affordable Italian-American cuisine. Fazoli's menu aims to satisfy a diverse array of tastes, featuring pasta, submarine sandwiches, salads, pizza, and desserts, among other items. Founded in 1988 by Jerrico, Inc., the same company known for Long John Silver's restaurants, Fazoli's initially aimed at serving quality Italian meals quick and fresh, a vision it continues to embody today.

Industry

Food and beverage stores

Company size

1,001 - 5,000 Employees

Headquarters location

Lexington, KY, US

Year founded

1988