ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Shift Supervisor Jobs in Wisconsin (NOW HIRING)

13 North

Shift Supervisor

Grafton, WI · On-site

$22/hr

We are seeking a motivated shift supervisor to oversee daily operations during designated shifts, supervise employees, and ensure that our customers receive exceptional service. The shift leader ...

Fazoli's

Shift Supervisor

Eau Claire, WI

$16 - $16.50/hr

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

Fazoli's

Shift Supervisor

Appleton, WI · On-site

$16/hr

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

Fazoli's

Shift Supervisor

West Allis, WI · On-site

$16 - $16.50/hr

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

Fazoli's

Shift Supervisor

Stevens Point, WI · On-site

$16/hr

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

Fazoli's

Shift Supervisor

Grand Chute, WI · On-site

$7.25 - $16.50/hr

Fazoli's is looking for qualified Shift Supervisors to do just that! Are you a natural leader with a passion for pasta, pizza, and creating a fun, fast-paced environment? Do you thrive in a place ...

F & M COMPANIES, INC.

2nd Shift Supervisor

Osceola, WI · On-site

Description The 2nd Shift Supervisor is responsible for overseeing all 2nd shift production activities within Oven Production and Secondary Operations (Punch Department). This position serves as the ...

F&M PLASTICS INC

2nd Shift Supervisor

Osceola, WI · On-site

The 2nd Shift Supervisor is responsible for overseeing all 2nd shift production activities within Oven Production and Secondary Operations (Punch Department). This position serves as the primary ...

F&M Plastics, Inc

2nd Shift Supervisor

Osceola, WI · On-site

The 2nd Shift Supervisor is responsible for overseeing all 2nd shift production activities within Oven Production and Secondary Operations (Punch Department). This position serves as the primary ...

Radius Packaging

Shift Supervisor

Delavan, WI · On-site

$13.50 - $17/hr

Night Shift Supervisor - 4-Day, 12-Hour Rotation Schedule Location: Delavan, WI Schedule: 4 days on / 4 days off | Oversight and Support for 12-hour shifts (rotational, including holidays) **Shift ...

MOD Super Fast Pizza, LLC

Shift Supervisor

Oak Creek, WI · On-site

$16.67/hr

Free counseling sessions Overview As a Shift Supervisor, you are building your leadership skills and style. You will lead restaurant operations during scheduled shifts and support training for all ...

MOD Pizza

Shift Supervisor

Sun Prairie, WI · On-site

$19.81/hr

Free counseling sessions Summary As a Shift Supervisor, you are building your leadership skills and style. You will lead restaurant operations during scheduled shifts and support training for all new ...

MOD Pizza

Shift Supervisor

Oak Creek, WI

$16.67/hr

Free counseling sessions Overview As a Shift Supervisor, you are building your leadership skills and style. You will lead restaurant operations during scheduled shifts and support training for all ...

MOD Super Fast Pizza, LLC

Shift Supervisor

Oak Creek, WI · On-site

$16.67/hr

Free counseling sessions Overview As a Shift Supervisor, you are building your leadership skills and style. You will lead restaurant operations during scheduled shifts and support training for all ...

Radius Packaging

Shift Supervisor

Delavan, WI · On-site

$13.50 - $17/hr

Night Shift Supervisor - 4-Day, 12-Hour Rotation Schedule Location: Delavan, WI Schedule: 4 days on / 4 days off Oversight and Support for 12-hour shifts (rotational, including holidays) **Shift ...

MOD Pizza

Restaurant Shift Supervisor

Lake Geneva, WI · On-site

$17.59/hr

Free counseling sessions Overview As a Shift Supervisor, you are building your leadership skills and style. You will lead restaurant operations during scheduled shifts and support training for all ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsShift Supervisor JobsShift Supervisor Jobs in Wisconsin

Shift Supervisor information

See Wisconsin salary details

$10

$16

$22

How much do shift supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Sep 14, 2026, the average hourly pay for shift supervisor in Wisconsin is $16.88, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $14.57 and $18.46 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a shift supervisor?

Shift supervisors are team leaders responsible for overseeing operations and employees during a specific shift. They ensure that work is completed efficiently, handle any issues that arise, and maintain communication between staff and management. Shift supervisors may also be responsible for scheduling, training new employees, and ensuring company policies are followed. Their role is crucial in maintaining smooth daily operations and providing support to both employees and customers.

How does a shift supervisor typically balance overseeing team performance with handling customer issues during a busy shift?

As a Shift Supervisor, you are expected to manage both staff and customer needs simultaneously, especially during peak hours. This involves delegating tasks efficiently, monitoring employee performance, and stepping in to resolve customer concerns promptly. Successful supervisors often rely on strong communication and time-management skills to keep the team motivated while ensuring customer satisfaction. It's common to collaborate closely with other supervisors or managers to address challenges as they arise and maintain smooth shift operations.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a shift supervisor, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Shift Supervisor, you need strong leadership, organizational skills, and experience in team management, often supported by a high school diploma or equivalent and relevant industry experience. Familiarity with scheduling software, point-of-sale systems, and inventory management tools is typically required. Exceptional communication, conflict resolution, and problem-solving abilities distinguish top performers in this role. These skills ensure smooth operations, high employee morale, and consistent achievement of business goals during each shift.

What is the difference between Shift Supervisor vs Team Leader?

AspectShift SupervisorTeam Leader
CredentialsHigh school diploma or equivalent; some roles may require certifications in safety or specific skillsHigh school diploma or equivalent; leadership or team management certifications are common
Work EnvironmentFast-paced settings like retail, hospitality, manufacturingSimilar environments, often in retail, customer service, or hospitality
Employer UsageSupervises daily operations, manages staff during shiftsLeads a team, focuses on team development and task completion

While both roles involve supervising staff and ensuring smooth operations, a Shift Supervisor typically oversees daily shift activities, focusing on operational tasks. A Team Leader emphasizes guiding and motivating team members to achieve goals. Both roles require similar credentials and work in comparable environments, but their focus areas differ slightly.

Can I be a shift supervisor with no experience?

Shift supervisor roles typically require some prior work experience, especially in customer service or team management, but many employers offer on-the-job training for candidates with strong communication and leadership skills. Having relevant certifications or a good work ethic can also improve your chances of being hired without previous supervisory experience.

How much do you make as a shift supervisor?

The average salary for a shift supervisor typically ranges from $12 to $20 per hour, depending on the industry, location, and experience. Many shift supervisors earn around $30,000 to $45,000 annually, with opportunities for overtime and bonuses. Compensation can also include benefits such as health insurance and paid time off.
More about Shift Supervisor jobs

What are the most commonly searched types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin?

The most popular types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin are:

What cities in Wisconsin are hiring for Shift Supervisor jobs?

Cities in Wisconsin with the most Shift Supervisor job openings:

Shift Supervisor jobs near you
Infographic showing various Shift Supervisor job openings in Wisconsin as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 73% Full Time, 21% Part Time, 3% Contract, and 2% Nights. Highlights an 98% Physical, and 2% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $35,100 per year, or $16.9 per hour.

Shift Supervisor

Grafton, WI • On-site

13 North
See more jobs at 13 Northexternal

$22/hr

Part-time

Posted 15 days ago

Job description

Benefits:
  • Competitive pay
  • Employee Discount
  • Opportunity for Growth
  • Dynamics Team Environment
  • Flexible schedule

13 North, formerly the Milwaukee Alehouse, has been serving the Grafton community and beyond for the past 20 years.  Our brand is an upscale, casual-style restaurant.  
We are dedicated to providing exceptional hospitality, positively impacting our community, and creating memorable experiences for every guest who walks through our doors.
We are seeking a motivated shift supervisor to oversee daily operations during designated shifts, supervise employees, and ensure that our customers receive exceptional service. The shift leader's responsibilities include creating a shift schedule, delegating tasks, and placing supply orders.
To be successful as a shift supervisor, you should be able to manage a team of people and ensure that all duties are performed accurately. Ultimately, a top shift supervisor should be able to ensure smooth and efficient workflow.
Responsibilities:

  • Supervising employees, assigning duties, and creating a shift schedule.
  • Monitoring team performance and ensuring duties are performed efficiently.
  • Reporting any issues that arise during the shift to management.
  • Managing employee requests and transgressions.
  • Ensuring compliance with company policies, health, and safety standards.
  • Coaching team members and training new staff.
  • Handling customer issues and employee disputes.
Requirements:

  • High school diploma/GED.
  • Previous experience as a Shift Supervisor or in a similar role in restaurants.
  • Experience creating shift schedules.
  • Excellent communication and interpersonal skills.
  • Strong leadership and organizational skills.
  • Confident problem-solver.
  • Team player.
If you’re passionate about making every guest's day brighter and thrive in a dynamic, fast-paced setting, we want to hear from you!
Come grow with us and help us continue setting the standard in hospitality.