1

Mutual Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Crown Point, IN · On-site

$61K - $250K/yr

Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path to ...

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Crown Point, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$61K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Carmel, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$61K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

Financial Advisor

Mishawaka, IN · On-site

$137K - $250K/yr

Overview Becoming a financial advisor at Northwestern Mutual is a unique opportunity to start a business where you can help your clients achieve their goals through financial planning. On your path ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Mutual information

What is the difference between Mutual vs Insurance Agent?

AspectMutualInsurance Agent
CredentialsTypically requires licensing and sometimes certifications in insurance productsRequires licensing; certifications vary by state and product
Work EnvironmentOften works for mutual insurance companies, focusing on policyholdersWorks for insurance agencies or companies, selling various insurance policies
Employer & Industry UsageCommonly employed by mutual insurance companiesEmployed by insurance agencies or companies across the industry
Search & Comparison IntentPeople compare mutual insurance providers or roles within mutual companiesIndividuals compare insurance agents for policy advice and sales

Mutual professionals typically work within mutual insurance companies, focusing on policyholder services, while insurance agents sell policies for various providers. Both roles require licensing and are integral to the insurance industry, but their work environments and employer types differ.

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Mutual jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Mutual job openings:

Infographic showing various Mutual job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% Internship, 1% As Needed, 83% Full Time, 12% Part Time, and 3% Contract. Highlights an 81% Physical, 5% Hybrid, and 14% Remote job distribution.

FARM MUTUAL UNDERWRITING - REINSURANCE

Indianapolis, IN

Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance
Insurance Services • 501 - 1,000 employees

$89K - $154K/yr

Full-time

Posted 15 days ago


Job description

The Underwriting Manager- Farm Mutual Reinsurance is responsible for operational underwriting of a mature, regional farm mutual reinsurance specialty portfolio. This role is critical to the underwriting activities relative to management of the reinsurance risk portfolio.   

This position has an assigned territory of Ohio and Indiana. The ideal candidate lives within the assigned territory and frequently travels within the assigned states.  Please note that candidates must be eligible to work in the U.S. without Grinnell Mutual sponsorship.


  • Underwrites a profitable portfolio of farm mutual reinsurance business by developing short- and long-term goals, strategies, and processes.
  • Accountable for underwriting property and casualty farm mutual regional reinsurance business, deploying capital and maximizing profits.
  • Identifies opportunities within territory portfolio that grows the business profitably. Utilizes catastrophe modeling and actuarial pricing teams to evaluate renewals and submissions.
  • Underwrites submissions/renewals, prices reinsurance programs, provides quotes, authorizes contracts and maintains relationships.
  • Provides expertise to members regarding business operations, risk management, and viability.
  • Attends internal and external meetings, including committee assignments and contributes to meetings by asking questions or presenting information verbally or in written form.
  • Cultivates culture of continuous improvement within the division by seeking opportunities to improve processes and efficiencies.
  • Remains current on industry trends, best practices, regulations, and profession. Applies knowledge to achieve optimal business results.
  • Ensures mutual partners have a sound business model to meet Grinnell Mutual standards and rates are consistent with contract obligations.
  • Responsible for executing all aspects of reinsurance underwriting and member consultation.
  • Significant projects, predictive analysis, and reinsurance relationships. Interacts with the brokers, division leader and cross division leaders.
  • All other duties as assigned.

  • Bachelor's degree from an accredited college or university with five (5) years of property casualty reinsurance related experience and a demonstrated skill set in best practices related to the reinsurance industry; or equivalent combination of education and experience.
  • Experience working with brokers and farm mutual regional accounts is preferred.
  • Industry designations preferred (eg. ARe, CPCU, CFA, CPA, FCAS).
  • Experience underwriting Property and Casualty Insurance, Property Catastrophe, Property Aggregate Excess, Per Risk, Quota Share and Multi-Line Excess.
  • Analytical and problem-solving skills to evaluate risk and potential profitability of accounts.
  • Experience with property reinsurance pricing methods including exposure and experience analysis for catastrophe and non-catastrophe perils.
  • Knowledge of third-party catastrophe modeling software products, their applicability to underwriting reinsurance business and evolution over time.
  • Knowledge of reinsurance contracts and general reinsurance terminology and processes.
  • Advanced knowledge and functional use of Excel for data analytics, Power BI software, or other simulation software.
  • Demonstratrd leadership skills and is a strong team player. Leads as a role model for division employees and the company, developing and executing corporate goals.
  • Ability to communicate persuasively, both orally and in writing, to professionally present information to a variety of groups and forums and present on topics as requested.
  • Demonstrated aptitude to make effective decisions using personal judgment, experience, facts, and figures to resolve problems and make decisions.
  • Demonstrated ability to broker consensus by involving stakeholders in the decision-making process to maintain relationships and mutual understanding.
  • Ability to work effectively and relate well with internal and external customers. Ability to exhibit a professional manner in dealing with and working to maintain constructive working relationship by utilizing good interpersonal communication skills. Ability to work in a harmonious manner with clients, co-employees and supervisor.
  • Must posses working knowledge of basic office equipment. Computer skills must include basic skills in Microsoft Office suite.
  • Ability to maintain a valid driver’s license and adhere to fleet safety policy. Ability to travel to customer’s offices or meeting sites. Overnight travel is required occasionally.

The salary range for the position is $89,138 - $154,850. For a list of benefits, click here.


To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each job duty and responsibility satisfactorily.  Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform job duties and responsibilities.

  • The Underwriting Manager -Farm Mutual Reinsurance may be required to work outside of normal business hours including occasional weekends to meet deadlines associated with the position.
  • The position can operate within a typical office setting located in an office or in a remote home office. The noise level in the work environment is usually quiet. The position requires an individual to sit for long periods of time. The position may require frequent and extended time on the telephone and visual acuity to work on the computer for extended periods of time.
  • This role has frequent external customer contact with insurers.
  • Frequently works with all levels of employees in the organization.

This job description is not intended to describe, in detail, the multitude of tasks that may be assigned, but rather to give the employee a general sense of the responsibilities and expectations of the position. As the nature of the business demands change, so too may the job duties and responsibilities.

Grinnell Mutual is an Equal Opportunity Employer in accordance with applicable state and federal laws.