ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Customer Service Supervisor Jobs in Indiana

Tjx

Part Time Customer Service Supervisor

Richmond, IN · On-site

$14.25 - $14.75/hr

Role models outstanding customer service. * Creates a positive internal and external customer ... HSA; health care FSA; life insurance; short/long term disability; paid parental leave; paid ...

KOHLS

Full-Time Customer Service Supervisor

Brownsburg, IN · On-site

$17.25 - $22/hr

... Supervisor roles at Kohl's are responsible for: * Leading with integrity, honesty and fostering ... Demonstrating and coaching a customer service mindset, including customer service philosophies ...

KOHLS

Full-Time Customer Service Supervisor

Madison, IN · On-site

$18.10 - $23.10/hr

... Supervisor roles at Kohl's are responsible for: * Leading with integrity, honesty and fostering ... Demonstrating and coaching a customer service mindset, including customer service philosophies ...

Kohl's

Full-Time Customer Service Supervisor

Brownsburg, IN · On-site

$17.25 - $22/hr

... Supervisor roles at Kohl's are responsible for: * Leading with integrity, honesty and fostering ... Demonstrating and coaching a customer service mindset, including customer service philosophies ...

Cintas

Service Supervisor

Muncie, IN · On-site

Responsibilities include supervising the service team who provides customer service, sales and the ... AD&D Insurance, 100% Company Paid Paid Time Off and Holidays Skills Development, Training and ...

Cintas

Service Supervisor

Muncie, IN · On-site

Responsibilities include supervising the service team who provides customer service, sales and the ... and AD&D Insurance, 100% Company Paid • Paid Time Off and Holidays • Skills Development ...

Cintas

Service Supervisor

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

Responsibilities include supervising the service team who provides customer service, sales and the ... AD&D Insurance, 100% Company Paid Paid Time Off and Holidays Skills Development, Training and ...

Cintas Corporation

Service Supervisor

Muncie, IN · On-site

Cintas is seeking a Service Supervisor to work directly with our customer facing service team both ... Disability, Life and AD&D Insurance, 100% Company Paid * Paid Time Off and Holidays * Skills ...

Cintas

Service Supervisor

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

Responsibilities include supervising the service team who provides customer service, sales and the ... and AD&D Insurance, 100% Company Paid • Paid Time Off and Holidays • Skills Development ...

previous pagenext page

Showing results 21-40

All JobsInsurance Customer Service Supervisor JobsInsurance Customer Service Supervisor Jobs in Indiana

Insurance Customer Service Supervisor information

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Insurance Customer Service Supervisor jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Insurance Customer Service Supervisor job openings:

Customer Service Supervisor, CMS

Westfield, IN • On-site

Carrington Holding Company
Finance and Insurance • 1 - 5K employees
Learn more about Carrington Holding Companyexternal

$64K - $74K/yr

Other

Medical, Retirement

Re-posted 10 days ago

Job description

Come join our amazing team and work a hybrid schedule!

The Customer Service Supervisor will oversee a unit within the Customer Service Department and monitor associate workload and performance to ensure consistent goal achievement. Perform all duties in accordance with the company’s policies and procedures, all US state and federal laws and regulations, wherein the company operates. The target pay range for this position is $64,480.00/yr to $74,480.00/yr plus monthly incentive bonus.

What you’ll do:

  • Supervise the entire operation of a unit within the Customer Service Department.
  • Carries out supervisory responsibilities in accordance with the organization’s policies and applicable laws, including training employees; planning, assigning, and directing work; monitoring performance; rewarding and disciplining employees; addressing complaints; and resolving problems.
  • Responsible for ensuring that corporate standards are communicated and consistently applied throughout the unit.
  • Review the unit’s daily productivity report and utilize monitoring systems to effectively evaluate and impact performance.
  • Assist in answering escalated borrower inquiries and answer complex/general questions from team.
  • Develop relationships and partner with internal departments to identify ways to maximize efficiencies and effectiveness across the departments.
  • Train, educate, assist and motive employees to meet and exceed set performance goals.
  • Create and maintain a motivating and positive working environment.
  • Monitor real time key performance metrics (KPI’s) to ensure proper coverage and identify continuous improvement opportunities.
  • Conduct team meetings to ensure the team is current on company’s policies, procedures and address training opportunities.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.

What you’ll need:

  • High school diploma or equivalent work experience.
  • Three (3) plus years’ customer service/call center experience in a high-volume telephone contact environment.
  • Two (2) years or more Mortgage Loan Servicing industry experience preferred.

Our Company:

Carrington Mortgage Services is part of The Carrington Companies, which provide integrated, full-lifecycle mortgage loan servicing assistance to borrowers and investors, delivering exceptional customer care and programs that support borrowers and their homeownership experience. We hope you’ll consider joining our growing team of uniquely talented professionals as we transform residential real estate. To read more visit:www.carringtonmortgage.com .

What We Offer:

  • Comprehensive healthcare plans for you and your family. Plus, a discretionary 401(k) match of 50% of the first 4% of pay contributed.
  • Access to several fitness, restaurant, retail (and more!) discounts through our employee portal.
  • Customized training programs to help you advance your career.
  • Employee referral bonuses so you’ll get paid to help Carrington and Vylla grow.
  • Educational Reimbursement.
  • Carrington Charitable Foundation contributes to the community through causes that reflect the interests of Carrington Associates. For more information about Carrington Charitable Foundation, and the organizations and programs, it supports through specific fundraising efforts, please visit:carringtoncf.org.

Notice to all applicants: Carrington does not do interviews or make offers via text or chat.

#LI-SY1

Job Info
  • Job Identification 4168
  • Job Category Customer Service/Support
  • Posting Date 06/30/2026, 08:06 PM
  • Job Schedule Full time
  • Locations 2100 E 196th St, Westfield, IN, 46074, US (Hybrid)
#J-18808-Ljbffr

Apply